But radio emissions swiftly degrade after not too long of a distance, so unless we build some kind of extremely high-powered transmitter then any scheme like this is doomed to failure. Luckily.
But radio emissions swiftly degrade after not too long of a distance, so unless we build some kind of extremely high-powered transmitter then any scheme like this is doomed to failure. Luckily.
"Conquering" stellar civilizations only happens in space operas.
- Aliens land in Beijing, Beijing people would ask the aliens if they believe in capitalism or socialism.
- Aliens land in Shanghai, Shanghai people would drag the aliens to the zoo to put on display.
- Aliens land in Guangdong, they would be eaten…
- Aliens land in Wenzhou, Wenzhou people will ask the aliens: is business easy to do on your planet?
I'm not claiming that any of this is certainty. It really is very difficult to predict. But I caution against anthropomorphic reasoning. I also think it would be wise to be cautious about taking these kinds of risks, if we can.
[1] http://www.projectrho.com/public_html/rocket/aliens.php#id--... [2] http://www.projectrho.com/public_html/rocket/spacegunexotic....
I think it's essentially impossible to predict what to expect from a point of view of specific technologies, and a more fundamental approach is more interesting: given the possible gains we might have, and the possible threats (termination should have a fair likelihood), the expected utility from contact should be hugely skewed negatively -- assuming -inf utility for termination and +finite for whatever gains.
We don't know what other destructive technologies are possible.
>the expected utility from contact should be hugely skewed negatively -- assuming -inf utility for termination and +finite for whatever gains.
If you are assuming death is -inf, almost any action has infinite negative utility. Also see pascal's mugging (http://lesswrong.com/lw/kd/pascals_mugging_tiny_probabilitie...).
The insane energy scales of relativistic travel (especially between .9 and .9999-repeating) combined with the ridiculously advanced technologies throws any speculation out of the window. Interstellar nukes surviving relativistic deep space travel while guiding themselves to a solar systems light years away (and with your ability to turn measure in tiny radians of the same)? Super-virus that operates across massive evolutionary scales while, again, surviving said travel (and for kicks only 240 of the known 500 amino acids are naturally occurring [1] and it depends entirely on random mutations and environment)? Self-replicating nanobots, one half of the holy grail (billions of years being the other) that would place in the hands of mortals that which allowed natural selection to give birth to the aforementioned aliens?
At the technological level of relativistic weapon systems + nanobots you're basically talking the ability to do whatever you wanted. If they can have near omnipotent self-replicating nanobots flying to destroy civilizations, why not to slightly shift their stellar orbit by consuming the rest of the solar system (relativistic guidance and navigation is an entirely different ordeal) to add some interstellar non-determenacy or send out nanobots to replicate their civilization on hospitable solar systems?
Sending out a bunch of relativistic nukes is probably going to be one hell of an expense (don't imagine you'd be able to do a gravitational sling shot without a black hole or perfect premonition). If the civilization was that scared of being wiped out, it'd probably be cheaper to build a single defense for their civilization rather than a bunch of attack platforms intended to wipe out other civilizations.
It's possible they can have dyson spheres, and artificial brains the size of planets, running far faster and more efficient computers and algorithms. This is of course just wild speculation, I'm only trying to give a sense of how absurdly far ahead of us they could be.
Interstellar travel is difficult yes, but possible. We've had the basic technology requirements for interstellar spaceship since the 50's (project Orion.) If you accept the premise that it's possible to send a reasonable size package (possibly as small as a pin if nanotechnology is possible) then wiping out a primitive planet doesn't seem so difficult.
>If the civilization was that scared of being wiped out, it'd probably be cheaper to build a single defense for their civilization rather than a bunch of attack platforms intended to wipe out other civilizations.
Possibly. It depends entirely on the costs of defense against advance civilizations vs the cost of wiping out primitive planets before they become a threat. We don't know what futuristic interstellar warfare would be like, but my guess is crushing intelligences before they advance to far, is far easier.
The technology necessary to reach out and destroy another civilization light years away cannot be developed in a vacuum. No matter how you accelerate the nuke, navigate it or protect the payload from the harsh realities of relativistic flight, you will develop an entire canon of technologies and an understanding of the universe that before you would ever be capable of identifying, let alone destroying, another intelligent civilization.
Atomic bombs would suggest a negative response.
Well, then you are also spread out, and given enough time, you spread throughout a galaxy. With that level of spread, the safety in numbers and distribution over a large space is a form of strong defense against relativistic weapons from other civilizations.
Furthermore, the technology for these weapons may also open up avenues for defense, even if such is not the case for nuclear weapons. Consider a relativistic missile detection system that continually scans for incoming missiles and is able to quickly accelerate its own for head-on collisions. Granted, there's not much notice. But let's say you have missiles at 0.99c - quite fast - and a light year away (would any closer be plausible for a launch? Maybe with relativistic ICBMs... or ISBMs rather). By my non-relativistic calculations, that gives you almost 90 hours to prepare countermeasures.
A "simpler" countermeasure is just to go overboard with the spreading idea. Simply live on millions of asteroids with your advanced propulsion tech slapped on. When a relativistic threat is detected, each asteroid is nimble enough to get out of the way, and if some are still hit, it's a small loss.
Though, the attacker could just shoot many smaller, faster missiles dispersed over a wide area. Not civilization-annihilating now, unless it was overwhelming in number, but still painful.
Couldn't they defeat it with their own nanotech? Well possibly. Perhaps the winning civilization is just slightly more advanced and has an advantage. Perhaps they slip in somewhere undetected and have time to mess things up before they can be stopped. Perhaps stopping nanobots from self-replicating is just harder to do than replicating.
Who really knows what technology is possible. An 18th century person never would have predicted machine guns and planes. A 19th century person couldn't have anticipated nuclear weapons. Few 20th century people probably even heard of nanotechnology. We can't guess a century of technological progress, let alone millions.
This one seems a little strange. They're like weaker bombs, only not as weak. What's not to anticipate?
If an alien species has the means to reach Earth, either sublight or FTL, chances are they sorted out their own problems as a civilisation and as such, could probably teach humanity a few things.
There are, however, still factors imaginable that might lead to a hostile (=genocidal) reaction from an advanced race - for example a reaction motivated by religion or paranoia. If we are within the reach of such a civilization they're already looking for us anyway though, it's unlikely additional harm will come from sending them a signal if they're already in the process of scouring the galaxy for places that are in need of a thorough ethnic cleansing.
The probability of such a scenario can currently not be estimated since we don't even have a single data point on other civilizations in our neighborhood. We don't even know if FTL is possible in practice, a technology without which an assault on Earth may very well be impractical for the foreseeable future.
One thing that might concern us, related to a potential explanation for the Fermi Paradox, is the possibility of attracting the attention of an embodied "great filter", for example in the shape of automated replicating drones that sweep the galaxy to eradicate all instances of technology they can find. But if such a filter exists, our eventual discovery will be inevitable anyway so sending an additional signal out into space would probably not make a difference.
It's difficult to construct a credible scenario where sending a signal will be instrumental in our destruction, mainly based on the assumption that interstellar civilizations or entities with the motivation to destroy us would likely not be content with sitting around on the off chance that another planet might contact them.
So who's our most likely recipient then? It's a civilization on a tech level comparable to our own. So for the sake of argument let's assume the roles are reversed:
One day we get an interstellar call. There's another inhabited star system out there, maybe not too far, let's say 200 light years away. Let's assume the worst and, upon receiving a friendly "hello" type message, the world goes completely crazy and decides the remote greeters need to DIE! At this point, there is really not much we can do to actualize that desire. We could build a huge generation ship and send it on its way but it's going to be traveling for thousands of years. When (if!) it arrives, the other civilization will either be gone or so far advanced that it's beyond the point where our puny aging low-tech generation ship can do any damage.
These are the assumptions we're operating under. Yes, they're assumptions, but for the most part they're based on the best we can do for reasoning and scientific knowledge today.
It's also possible they might simply want to quarantine Earth as wars, religion and poverty are still present, and they wouldn't want them to spread to the rest of the galaxy.
It seems like the purpose of sending a signal is ultimately to get aliens to visit us. But the diseases they bring with them do have a high probability of wiping us out (or us wiping them out).
I suppose if both sides are very careful, or if we restrict ourselves to communication only, then it could be all right. But why go looking for more problems when we haven't even solved our own? And we probably never will.
One reason to be searching for a new civilization is to steal their technology. The first nation that's willing to do this stands to dominate every other nation, so there's a big incentive for us to steal their tech as long as the concept of nations still exist.
And of course, if the aliens somehow didn't already have nuclear technology, then transmitting our Wikipedia to them might prove disastrous for them.
That's almost certainly beyond the capabilities of either civilization, but sure in the long term there's the benefit of already having some like-minded friends when we do get that capability.
> But the diseases they bring with them do have a high probability of wiping us out (or us wiping them out)
Again, considering the type of civilization we're trying to contact that's so far in the future it's not of immediate concern. What dangers both world pose to each other biologically would have to be studied carefully as data becomes available. There are certain things we can almost certainly exclude as disease carriers, such as viruses or other vectors that are tightly coupled to the host's biochemistry. Parasites and vermin might become a problem on both ends if living conditions are compatible enough (which is another big question mark).
> But why go looking for more problems when we haven't even solved our own?
We're not looking for problems, we're trying to contact people to at least gain some scientific knowledge but if possible also to get some serious motivation going towards technological advancement. Cooperation between two comparable but entirely separate civilizations has the potential to be very fruitful for both.
> One reason to be searching for a new civilization is to steal their technology.
Well, it's not like we'll pop in and steal their iPhones ;) If they choose to transmit scientific and engineering data, that's not stealing either (copying is not stealing). I would imagine such an exchange to be very cautious in the beginning. It might not even be feasible to transmit time-critical knowledge, however. Still, it's always of interest to compare notes, and I imagine scientists on both sides would welcome an extended conversation if posssible.
> so there's a big incentive for us to steal their tech as long as the concept of nations still exist
If they transmit the blueprint for some really advanced stuff, sure, there'd be the usual power shenanigans here on Earth. But at the moment, that's not a concern as the first messages back and forth would most likely be very limited in scope. Even establishing a common communications format might take several hundred years.
> if the aliens somehow didn't already have nuclear technology, then transmitting our Wikipedia to them might prove disastrous for them
It's unlikely they'd be able to communicate but at the same time not have mastered basic physics. There will be things that each side is more advanced at - for example it's conceivable that Earth has better information technology but lags behind its potential in energy production.
The biggest boost an open phone line can provide would probably be psychological, long before a meaningful science collaboration could be orchestrated. Just knowing there are other people out there is of tremendous value.