If you profile your code, you don't go after the line item that's < .1% until everything else is fixed; I'd argue that our representatives have more substantive budget fixes they can target.
If you profile your code, you don't go after the line item that's < .1% until everything else is fixed; I'd argue that our representatives have more substantive budget fixes they can target.
That's how we get such a bloated federal budget. It's why Congress wants to build a whole bunch of tanks for the Army that they have said they don't need. It's really more of a tragedy of the commons situation than inefficiency.
IMO the question shouldn't be "how can we lower our tax burden", it should be "how do we get more value out of our tax dollars." That may mean increasing the tax burden. There's a sweet spot between socialism and capitalism, and IMO we're swinging a bit far towards capitalism right now. I'm not saying we should go full-on welfare state, but our infrastructure is crumbling and people are losing faith in the American dream, yet companies are more profitable than ever.
It's also important to recognize that government accounting is substantially different from normal corporate accounting. Governments can literally print money if they need to do so to cover debts (and thus shift the burden of debt repayment onto all holders of their currency). The flip side of that is that governments have such a massive scale, they tend to absorb a lot of economy-scale losses (such as building vacancies) that businesses wouldn't have to, so their balance sheets look awful.
But small businesses would know if a chair was underutilized, and it would be sold in 10 minutes; let alone a whole building. Taken over the whole economy, these efficiencies are a big deal, and arguably account for the success of market economy over centrally-planned economies.
Right-O, no waste in small businesses. The smaller the business, the more efficient. Hence ever-smaller businesses are gaining a growing share of the economy. (In fact, the opposite is true.)
I didn't say that; no need for the sarcasm.
The answer is somewhat complicated. Small businesses have an advantage because the information flow between directly involved parties and decision makers is very short; possibly the same person. They can notice an inefficiency and correct it immediately, rather than needing some kind of permission or authorization (which is inherently a slow way for information to travel because it involves other people). They can also seize opportunities quickly for the same reason (which may involve changing prices or making a non-traditional deal).
Large businesses can get economies of scale, although I think these are dramatically over-emphasized. Producing one marginal unit may be cheaper up to a point, but eventually the next marginal unit becomes more costly than the last (because there becomes so much demand for the inputs that it increases the price). That's the nature of the supply curve. Often, businesses that deal in huge volumes and have great economies of scale are medium-sized or even small. Of course, there are some industries where economies of scale are crucial and only large businesses or governments can really operate efficiently.
Large businesses have greater political influence and more ability to work in a regulated/political/government environment. This is perhaps their greatest advantage.
I'd be interested to see the numbers you have about the share of the economy powered by small/medium businesses. Is it a long, consistent decline, or more of a local minimum?
Fair enough. To be fair, you did overstate the point a bit; I'm sure we will all walk into a small business today that could do with one less chair. :-)
>> I'd be interested to see the numbers you have about the share of the economy powered by small/medium businesses. Is it a long, consistent decline, or more of a local minimum?
There's a lot of research out there on this. I don't have the time to dig up much more than this:
http://www.sba.gov/sites/default/files/rs390tot_0.pdf
Note that in 12 years, small businesses lost ~6% of their GDP contribution to larger businesses (table 5). In 2010, small business share of the economy fell below 50% for the first time ever (http://www.businessweek.com/articles/2012-02-16/small-busine...).
A more libertarian type might say that the increasing power of government is driving small business out through various types of intervention. Evidence would include the ever-increasing share of GDP made up by government spending. This would be countered by the fact that you can still start most kinds of businesses with remarkably little federal involvement aside from taxation.
Someone more inclined toward central planning might say that the information age is making central planning more effective. Evidence would include companies like amazon that have amazing reach. That would be countered by the observation that there are still a lot of small businesses that sell through amazon and set their own prices; and amazon has many robust competitors for each product they sell.
In other words, at least the boat is actually potentially useful. The empty building is completely wasteful.
So, it's a values difference, then.
Yeah, difference of values is fairly spot on. I don't know anybody who values an empty building, though. Or didn't, until now?
I understand where you're argument is - at least we get some use out of the big boat. I just don't like it, and would prefer to see the buildings be paid for overtop of weapons.
Man, that makes me sound like a giant hippy now that I've written it out.
At the risk of pushing this thread well past the point of usefulness and too far into the abstract, you know the building could be used to quarter troops, store weapons, etc, so long as it is owned by the government, even not in time of war? Personally, I value the government owning large weapons more than I value them owning millions of small weapons. The large weapons are more likely to be used under the correct circumstances. I think that's part of why we overuse (IMHO) drones - it made it cheap to wage asymmetric warfare.
It's a matter of design versus function. The buildings could be re-purposed for war, but they weren't expressly designed for it.
My point is that available effort to resolve any problem is roughly finite. Fixing the regulations to solve this problem would involve Congressional time and attention, and that applying that attention to a larger problem could lead to much larger gains.
I'm not saying this is good waste, I'm saying that all things being equal it makes sense to rank problems by potential impact and then start near the top.