and the point being that the service allows copyright infringement? Not being sarcastic, I'm genuinely trying to understand.
That being said, if this site gives much more opportunity to making profit from copyright infringement, then it's more likely to become a target for 'pirates' trying to make a quick buck out of other people's copyright work.
The site can do something similar to what youtube is doing, which is to forfeit any profits if a copyright complaint is made (and maybe even giving those profits to the original copyright holder). This could deter / nullify infringements at least in theory.
It is rather complex and difficult process to manage, so any site hosting user-generated content should consider those implications.