This is usually the process one needs to follow, albeit with some intermediate steps switched out for others here and there.
This is usually the process one needs to follow, albeit with some intermediate steps switched out for others here and there.
If you want to learn statistics, it's probably better to start at the beginning (_Cartoon Guide to Statistics_, O'Reilly's new _Head First Statistics_, or Huff's _How to Lie With Statistics_) than to leap headlong into a huge, mostly intractable problem and pagefault in knowledge at each point you come across something you don't know how to do.
Don't tell Google that it's slogan ("Organize the world's information") is biting off more than it could chew.
Still, there is a place for an introductory book if you are truly coming from minimal knowledge of the subject.
This is true, but I think in the original poster's case it could be much more easily and reliably be accomplished by continually giving him problems that are within (or more ideally, just outside) his circle of competence, rather than a problem like "predict stock prices" which isn't in any human being's circle of competence. Moreover, with the latter problem, he'll get virtually no feedback as to whether his answer was correct, because a correct answer for "use statistics to predict stock prices" doesn't exist. Odds are that if he follows that path he'll quit before making any progress, or at the least he won't be able to close the feedback loop that is so vital to gaining expertise.
I think that if he's starting from ground zero and wanting to learn statistics, he'd be much better served by sitting down with The Cartoon Guide to Statistics and a deck of cards and set of dice first. He can work his way up to conquering the stock market :)
Don't tell Google that it's slogan ("Organize the world's information") is biting off more than it could chew.
I think that's apples and oranges - he's trying to learn statistics, not trying to convince potential clients or investors that he's already an expert. I don't think it would be harmful at all for him to have a lofty, far-out goal like "predict stock prices" to aim toward, but I do think that if he starts out trying to learn statistics by typing "statistical stock prediction methods" into Google, he will burn out rather quickly. Pagefaulting in knowledge when you need it is probably optimal for something where you just want to make sure your knowledge is passable, but if he wants to truly know his domain, he's gotta get out the marbles and urns. :)
They came up with that slogan well after they were already experts in search, and probably after Google had been written and they'd formed a company. To hear Larry tell it, Google started with the question of "What if we could download all of the web and just keep all the links?" And then Terry Winograd encouraged them, and they realized that the link structure of the web was a lot like the citation graph of academic publications. And then they realized they could build a kick-ass search engine by using that to rank page relevance. And then when nobody would license it, they formed a company.
The way to build massive world-changing systems isn't to start with massive world-changing ideas. It's to start with interesting, challenging, but tractable problems, and then see where they lead you.
The other problem with this approach is that while you may get depth, there is very little breadth. I find that when learning something for the first time, I want to go wide and shallow. Then once I have a basic understanding I can figure out where I want to learn deeper.
OTOH, maybe you just learn things differently from me!
I just gave my friend (a PhD in Operations Research) his basic Statistical Theory book back. I also wanted to get a better understanding of statistics, but that stuff was putting me to sleep too easily :-(