USM holds pilot in which students use free 'open-source' textbooks
baltimoresun.com
baltimoresun.com
A book by the same name by Charles Stangor, University of Maryland and used for PSCY 100 classes there, so more than likely the book discussed in the article, is also available free at https://open.umn.edu/opentextbooks/BookDetail.aspx?bookId=48 but paid and you can also get v2.0! at https://students.flatworldknowledge.com/course/1315333
this is not to say there is not career advantage in writing "the standard book on", but stuffing a few hundred students each year is hardly the lottery win.
But [David Anderson, executive director of higher
education at the Association of American Publishers] said
traditional textbooks can cost up to a few million dollars
to produce, and he is skeptical that such an effort can be
re-created on a large scale for a product distributed for
free.
Of course, there are multiple open-source software projects that would take hundreds of millions of dollars worth of development effort to do again. To me, the number he's quoting seems like so little effort that it's almost absurd to think you couldn't do it. But if you're not in the software development industry, I guess these things aren't obvious.And the related issue is the use of "open source" to describe a process that does not seem to allow contributions from the public, which is of course how those software projects became so big in the first place:
Roberts estimated that he spent 80 hours pulling
together open-source materials for his textbook, working
late into the night to write some sections himself when he
could not find good material.
I'm not entirely sure, but I think the paper (and the professor) think that "open source" development means putting together class materials that are freely available online. The trouble is that the economic advantage of open source software development is essentially that it is cheaper for someone else, not the original author of the project, to fix a few bugs in an existing open source project rather than starting from scratch. That is why people fix those bugs, and why open source projects grow. If you're not allowing (or really, actively soliciting) those contributions, you can't take advantage of this effect.In summary: using open source textbook materials is a great idea, but it would be better if they learned from how the software industry does it.
they get it. The excellent annual conference is on now (ish) and will have everyone from small town professors to udacity and the stonkingly-gets-it Charles S Burrus who is actually running a coursera EE course where they send thousands of multimeters, PCbs and tools out to students so they can do the actual EE parts.
trust me the folks involved get it. I wish I had written up those blog posts now so I could link you
I'm not entirely sold on the idea that every student having a tablet or laptop is the most effective use of education money. I tend to lean more towards having classroom sets of laptops or tablets and a active learning/ combined media class room setup.