> Keybase never has to know what your private key is or store it. So, yes, you are completely free to continue managing your private and public keys however you are used to.
And if they did require my private key I could always just not use the service at all. This is sortof besides the point. I'm not concerned about being coerced into anything. I'm concerned that they're sending the wrong message. Do you remember when Facebook used to ask for your Gmail password before we had OAuth? Do you think that was cool too?
> like you say, it's too early to trust them with everything
I'm not saying it's too early to trust them with everything. I'm saying you should never trust anybody with your private key. I don't care if it's my best friend, giving my private key to somebody is one more place it can get discovered. PGP offers something unique in that it can give you a network without any trust. You can weather the storm of broken https and MITMs and get to the person you're talking to. The only thing it doesn't fix is somebody owning your desktop. This is a beautiful thing if you think about it, and this sort of thing would dilute it.