Building a Global, Diverse, Inclusive Mozilla Project: Addressing Controversy
blog.lizardwrangler.com
blog.lizardwrangler.com
Also, everyone who has an opinion on this topic should read what Christie Koehler -- someone who most definitely has skin in this game -- wrote about Brendan's appointment: http://subfictional.com/2014/03/24/on-brendan-eich-as-ceo-of...
----------
Monday’s announcement of Brendan Eich as the new CEO of Mozilla brought a lot of reactions. Many people were excited about what this meant for Mozilla, and our emphasis on protecting the open Web. In the next few days we’ll see more from Brendan and the leadership team on the opportunities in front of us. Before that, however, both Brendan and I want to address a particular concern that has been raised about Mozilla’s commitment to inclusiveness for LGBT individuals and community, and whether Brendan’s role as CEO might diminish this commitment at Mozilla.
The short answer: Mozilla’s commitment to inclusiveness for our LGBT community, and for all underrepresented groups, will not change. Acting for or on behalf of Mozilla, it is unacceptable to limit opportunity for anyone based on the nature of sexual orientation and/or gender identity. This is not only a commitment, it is our identity.
This commitment is a key requirement for all leadership within Mozilla, including for the CEO, and Brendan shares this commitment as the new Chief Executive Officer.
Second, I’ll point to Brendan’s comments [1] on this topic.
Third, I’ll note that two years ago we had an open conversation and co-creation process about how we make sure our community supports all members, including all forms of gender and sexual orientation. The process, with me as the draftsperson, resulted in the Community Participation Guidelines [2]. These Guidelines mandate that (1) each of us must be inclusive of all community members, regardless of sexual orientation, gender identity and more, and (2) any exclusionary approach you might practice elsewhere must be left at the door, and not be brought into Mozilla’s spaces.
We expect everyone, regardless of role or title, to be committed to the breadth of inclusiveness described in the Guidelines. These Guidelines are in addition to our inclusive and non-discriminatory policies which apply particularly to employees. As a practical, concrete example we’ve also been pushing the boundaries to offer excellent health benefits across the board, to domestic partners and all married couples, same-sex and otherwise.
My experience is that Brendan is as committed to opportunity and diversity inside Mozilla as anyone, and more so than many. This commitment to opportunity for all within Mozilla has been a key foundation of our work for many years. I see it in action regularly.
The CEO role is obviously a key role, with a large amount of authority. The CEO must have a commitment to the inclusive nature of Mozilla. This includes of course a commitment to the Community Participation Guidelines, inclusive HR practices and the spirit that underlies them. Brendan has made this commitment.
Finally, I’ve been asked a few times about my own personal views, and so I’ll add a short comment.
I am an avid supporter of equal rights for all. I support equal rights for the LGBT community, I support equal rights for underrepresented groups, and I have some pretty radical views about the role of underrepresented groups in social institutions. I was surprised in 2012 to learn that Brendan and I aren’t in close alignment here, since I’ve never seen any indication of anything other than inclusiveness in our work together.
I spend most of my time focused on building an open Internet, which I think is a required infrastructure for empowerment for everyone and where I think I can add something that’s tricky to replace. If I weren’t doing this, I’d probably be spending a good chunk of my life focused more directly on equality issues.
[1] https://brendaneich.com/2014/03/inclusiveness-at-mozilla/ [2] http://www.mozilla.org/en-US/about/governance/policies/parti...
Personally, I don't see much of a gain to be had here. If it were a for-profit company, I'd probably boycott them, not because it helps the cause of marriage equality at all, but because punishing people who are jerks feels good. But it's Mozilla, an organization whose goals I support. I don't care if it's led by a jerk. Punishing him doesn't make the world a better place at all.
But Mozilla is a non-profit with a manifesto. They go to great lengths to describe their principles -- what they believe is right and will make the world a better place. While I know technical ability and business savvy are still important to the CEO of Mozilla, I would expect them to put more importance on whether or not their CEO is a jerk.
I don't really want to rehash the whole Eich debate from a couple days ago, but I thought it was interesting we have completely different opinions on how to hold different types of companies responsible.
Because discrimination doesn't always consist of large decisions.
The CEO gets a large say in things like benefits--he can choose a plan that is a little different because it would extend coverage on something that primarily affects the LGBT community.
The CEO can make subtle decisions on hiring. Like tends to hire like--so if there are two candidates at a higher level and he chooses the one that is anti-LGBT--that's an effect.
Discrimination is even always conscious. Look at the reaction time test in "Blink" by Gladwell for data. It will come across as "I like that guy!"--well, you like that guy because he seems to share the same value set as you. The fact that that value set is "anti-LGBT" means that more of those kinds of people are going to wind up in leadership positions.
A CEO is making decisions all the time that influence the system in subtle ways. People have a genuine right to be upset about this.
<rant>
You claim that "punishing jerks feels good".
I'm sorry, but this just comes across as silly internet power-tripping.
And who are you to claim somebody is a "jerk".
Brendan Eichs has personal beliefs, which I presume you don't agree with.
Whoop-de-do. Somebody is on the internet who you don't agree with. Cry me a river.
In the olden days, gentleman would simply say, we agree to disagree, and leave it at that.
Now, in this age of entitlement, every little boy in his mum's basement just has to get everybody to agree with him, because other peopel ARE WRONG (according to me).
You're free to write blog posts saying you disagree with him.
Or if you think he's wrong, you can even talk to him directly - in fact, he made a offer that he's happy to speak to anybody in private about it.
If anything, he comes across as the bigger person.
However, to go around saying, "BRENDAN IS A JERK" - sure, you're "free" to do it - free speech and all, but seriously, it comes across as immature and childish...
</rant>
However, I agree with the rest of your post - Mozilla does good work. I don't use their browser, but they do a lot for the open-source movement.
And racism is most definitely not equitable to arguing over what's a marriage, and what's not.
If this imaginary white supremacist was just some weirdo who genuinely thinks white people are superior, I would probably just label him a strange, somewhat deluded man - I wouldn't hate him though.
However, I probably wouldn't invite him over for dinner, either.
If, on the other hand, he was going around calling for lynching blacks, that's an entirely different matter - that's illegal (hate crimes).
Brandon Eichs hasn't expressed any homophobia, or that he "hates" gays, which is what people seem to be trying to drum up publicity for.
He simply has, in his private time, given him support for maintaining the status quo on marriage. You might disagree with that, and think that marriage should be redefined, and that's your right (just as it's his right).
But if you descend to the level of name-calling, and saying "Your view is like, so wrong! I'm right!", then we've already lost.
For those of you who insist that all this is "just politics", would you say the same if he contributed $1000 to a campaign to bring back slavery? What about a campaign to remove women's voting rights? One thing for sure - the degree of uproar would be drastically higher in those cases, and that's precisely the problem.
EDIT: why the downvotes? This is exactly what lending financial support to the Californian Proposition 8 implies.
This is inflamed by the fact that Eich has refused to apologize for this. Therefore, everyone is making the, quite justified, assumption that he believes in his anti-LGBT positions quite strongly.
If they had the slightest awareness of their environment, they would have started the softening-up PR months ago, when he started moving toward the CEO role. They could have had everything nicely calm. But no ...