What if he donated to the NRA or a pro-GMO campaign for example? Would there be similar uproar? This is just mob rule.
* I'm making no statement as to whether I agree with either side.
What if he donated to the NRA or a pro-GMO campaign for example? Would there be similar uproar? This is just mob rule.
* I'm making no statement as to whether I agree with either side.
More importantly IMHO, you could just as logically argue that any CEO who contributed to Republican campaigns is just as guilty as Eich for working to oppose gay marriage. Individual Republicans' opinions aside, the Republican Party is still running on an opposition platform as of April 2013 after all, and that party has done far more to hurt gay marriage rights than Prop. 8 by itself.
Eich is being crucified because he's a viable target, not because of any innate guilt that he alone is imbued with. I find that quite hypocritical.
Not really. I don't think there was a single Republican candidate that campaigned on the issue of gay marriage and nothing else. There is also a message of fiscal conservatism, pro-business stances, etc. etc.
Donating money to Prop 8 was a simple and straightforward move to try to block gay marriage, and absolutely nothing else.
That would imply that it would be acceptable to associate with dirty anti-gay marriage types if they were otherwise politically useful, would it not?
And if that's the case then I do not see how you could logically then "boycott Mozilla" as a consequence of Eich's appointment as CEO, since Mozilla actually does tons of good for people.
> Donating money to Prop 8 was a simple and straightforward move to try to block gay marriage, and absolutely nothing else.
Be that as it may, the vibe I'm getting from Eich's opponents is precisely that "you're either with us or against us". And moreover, that commingling good deeds with foul ones is no excuse. After all I would hope that it's only a very few that think "Mussolini made the trains run on time" was an excuse for all the rest.
Given that we're tying Eich to a stake here he must have done something really bad, and if it's that bad it's the kind of thing you don't outweigh just by going "Well I also voted against Obamacare!".
Again, no single political group has done more to oppress homosexuals from being able to marry than the GOP, however you dress it up. If opposing gay marriage is automatically a bad enough crime to warrant Eich's treatment then it should be bad enough irrespective of other, "nicer" opinions.
After all, Eich himself surely has "good" opinions we'd mostly agree with, would he not? He may even be on the whole good for the community, but no one has accorded him the opportunity of a trial or even thought very hard about whether his "goods" outweigh his "bad".
Except that no one is doing that. There's a pretty vast gulf between boycott and witch-burning.
If you don't think mine is the right comparison, that's fine, but if you're interested in understanding the other point of view as I assume you are, there it is.
No, because noone see those causes as being founded in fear and hate.
EDIT: changed wording for clarity
Also, to the downvoters Do you really think we would have heard about all this as much if it were related to other issues?
(and in all of those cases, the death tolls are higher.)
It's easy for people (especially certain middle-to-high income bracket liberal demographics) to give a pass on hating NRA/rednecks/religious folks while at the same time remaining indignant about what is an issue effecting a small subset of the population.
Moreover, while there are very valid arguments to be made in support of gay rights (usually by way of personal liberty, freedom of association, privacy, etc.), you really need to be willing to apply them to folks you don't like.
There is a serious lack of empathy in the viewpoint the parent describes. The premise that "anyone who disagrees with x is motivated by fear and hate" is a very dangerous one.