In general these are valid remarks. But we're not talking about random clueless people deciding to play statistics, the research is obviously conducted by people who know how this kind of stuff (statistics) works. This reminds me of laypeople trying to poke holes in theories of physics (and I'm not talking about quacks and lunatics, just well intentioned people who think they have a better explanation based on rudimentary high school or even undergraduate science and math). It's such a charming, cute naivete. Do they really think their simple ideas never occurred to a single professional physicist who immediately saw it was wrong for a number of reasons?
So, do you really think the researchers in this case hadn't thought of this? I mean yeah, it's OK to doubt and inquire, but come on, this is so rudimentary...
> If the questions are all yes/no questions
The article says (or at least implies) that the subjects give probabilities of "yes" to each question.
EDIT: Oh, and to add, the article clearly says they're not just making shit up and randomly coming up with probabilities. They collect open source info on events and base their estimates on that. So it's not just blind guessing.