Hacker News Reader

Comment by anigbrowl | Hacker News Reader

Transpermia seems like a theory rather than a fact. While I think you're probably correct, it's better to be ultra-conservative on questions like this.

View on HN

Of course it is only a theory, but a very plausible one given the frequency of rock transfer between planets and the toughness of microbes that allow them to survive in space for long time periods (both empirical facts).

There is really no way of proving transpermia - even if we to travel to Enceladus and found microbial life there how would we ever prove how it got there.

If we find DNA based microbial life it could certainly be amazing evidence in favor of transpermia. We would at least compare to DNA on earth and analyze similarities. Even plant and animal DNA are very similar (double helix shape)

Actually the easiest way to find life is to just look for DNA (or even better RNA) in the environment of interest. This is basically the way life is found in some of the amazing environments here on earth like the "lost city [0] or far under the earth [1].

Because of the technical simplicity and sensitivity of looking for DNA, any probe sent to any planet or moon would look for DNA first, basically assuming transpermia is true.

[0] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lost_City_(hydrothermal_field)

[1] http://aem.asm.org/content/74/1/143.full

> given the frequency of rock transfer between planets

What is this frequency, exactly? My impression was that all planets are constantly bombarded with rocks from space (not from other planets), but that it would be extremely surprising for a rock to e.g. leave Earth and end up on Mercury.

Link 0 suggests that 150 kg of rock ends up on Mars every year from Earth. It is not too hard to find rocks from Mars here on Earth.

The point of this story is to demonstrate facts that make transpermia less of a theory and more of a reality. We're not there yet - so don't throw the baby out with the bathwater here. We're absolutely going to go there to find life.

And make sure to check the bathwater closely before you toss that.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com