Thoughts on the pros and cons of either approach with respect to improving information security infrastructure?
Thoughts on the pros and cons of either approach with respect to improving information security infrastructure?
No, many BSD licensed projects have been created through other means. Partial sponsorship and user contributions (usually non-monetary) seems like a common path.
The problem with taxation is that it requires force, which implies a heavy burden of responsibility on the people allocating the funds after collection. It's really hard to figure out which projects should get funded, and how much, and avoid strange incentives along the way. I just don't think any group of humans could do a good job of this outside of very specific tactical funding (e.g. what the DoD does with some projects).
That's where a trusted intermediary probably has to come into play. The best thing I can think of at the moment is a version of Kickstarter that vets the candidate projects almost as thoroughly as a VC would and takes a cut for providing that service. Not sure how the business economics would play out in practice, though.
I imagine if the NSA was focused on defending businesses and not reading emails of people, they wouldn't be getting the same amount of financing. They are financed for their power to exploit people the government feels threatened by, not their ability to defend citizens from harm.
[1] - http://reason.com/24-7/2014/04/11/nsa-allegedly-knew-about-m...
In particular, I'd like to point out the "Privileged group" solution, which can occur when some individuals or organisations obtain enough personal benefit from a public good that they're basically willing to fund the good themselves, even if others are free riding. Many organisations obtain enough personal benefit from secure communications that it's worth it for them to contribute to OpenSSL.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Public_good#Privileged_group
There are lots of other ways of encouraging funding too. Hacker News is one place where the community constructs social norms around open source contributions.