It's also not a behaviour unique to the SF Bay Area; when I lived in a fairly rural area (pop. < 10K spread over quite a few miles), the largest city nearby was often referred to as "the city" by everyone that lived outside the largest nearby city (which was Kansas City where I lived).
It's "I went into The City" that I will not abide.
In fact, I've never seen anyone refer to any city that way except a minority of people in and around SF.
This is why South Park characterized residents of the city as "in love with the smell of their own farts."
http://www.usingenglish.com/forum/threads/17423-Rule-for-cap...
Geographic regions should be capitalized when they refer unambiguously to only one place. A capitalized "the City" implies that "the City" only refers to San Francisco, which is pretty pompous to many other people around the Globe.
If this were a Bay Area-only forum, however, it would be justified, as "the City" is pretty unambiguously SF within the Bay Area.
I have no idea what changed.