When ‘Liking’ a Brand Online Voids the Right to Sue
nytimes.com
nytimes.com
When I am effectively the server's server via running code on my machine, it seems like I have exactly the same right to declare unilateral terms-and-conditions for the use of my resources.
X-Client-ToS-Policy: TOS_ACCEPT=NONE,"By providing me a web page, you agree that our relationship has no additional terms or agreements beyond those already established in law."
It's machine readable and provided before the page is delivered, so it should be at least as enforcible as the nonsense "terms" businesses seem to like these days.Customer protection laws are meaningless if the only way to become a customer is to give up your rights protected in those laws. Of course smart, well-informed consumers will automatically avoid becoming customers of those companies, but who the hell visits a webpage to read a boring policy before picking a box of cereal from the shelf?
These kind of attempts to take away consumer rights shouldn't just be void, they should be illegal. Simply suggesting that consumers might have given up their rights, should by itself be worthy of a fine.
All these companies are essentially doing is claiming that you are giving up your rights. It remains to be seen whether these provisions will actually hold up with legal force in court (I doubt most of them will).
I think the states need to set up some basic standards for how some of these agreements need to happen, and make them very clear. For instance, there could be a law that if you sign away your right to sue, it must be in writing.
Why not make it a crystal-clear law, so that an ordinary citizen can understand without having to dig through case law and see what applies to their situation.
Because its an application of existing laws, and creating a separate law for it would be much the same problem in law as excessively tight coupling is in software development.
> so that an ordinary citizen can understand without having to dig through case law and see what applies to their situation.
Because making the ordinary citizen have to dig through statute law isn't much different, and because unless all change to all other laws that might interact with it and have apparent conflicts that might need to be resolved by the courts stopped (which it wouldn't), the ordinary citizen would still need to dig through case law to know what it meant in practice.
An example many people are familiar with are parking lots which display signs with 'We accept no liability...' or similar language. I had my car parked at a hotel in a direct line of sight and close to the front desk and it was vandalised by two men attempting to steal it. They had the hood up, trying to defeat the security system and were trying to saw through the steering wheel to remove a 'Club' steering lock for over an hour while I slept. All of this plus bored front desk attendants on CCTV.
I woke up to find this in the morning and asked the hotel about it. They acknowledged seeing what happened and admitted doing nothing. This was a nice car at a luxury hotel, too!
I informed the manager they would be taking responsibility for the damage and he did the usual 'We aren't liable' nonsense. I sued in small claims court and won a judgement and collected. The hotel is probably still ahead of the game by denying others' claims, but I challenged this and won. I hope more people will try it too.
Because, after all, your statutory rights are the law, and small print can't take that away from you, no matter how much "even thinking about buying our cereal creates a binding legal contract between us" or other such horseshit.