Half-Billion-Year-Old Heart Found More Complex than Today’s
biosciencetechnology.com
biosciencetechnology.com
[1] http://www.talkorigins.org/faqs/comdesc/
Evolution is not a relentless forward march, and if it could have inclinations, streamlining its productions would not be one of them. Doing so only when necessary, in cases where replication is also somehow advantaged. Usually... http://c2.com/cgi/wiki?ItAintBroke
Epistemically, what's going on, I think, is that evolution is pretty much assumed to be true and from the evidence it's only concluded what results it had.
With that said, life as we know it has a penalty on needless complexity. And, what does complex mean anyway? Complex genotype or complex phenotype? What is a good metric for measuring each one? Whatever the metrics are, it cannot be said that they are related monotonically. In this sense, we have four permutations of complexity i.e.[simple genotype, simple phenotype], [simple genotype, complex phenotype], [complex genotype, simple phenotype] and [complex genotype, complex phenotype]. Life as we know it is defined in the whereabouts of the genotype level. The "penalty" is on the [complex genotype, complex phenotype] type of complexity primarily because of the inaccuracy in the cell division process/processes (life as we know it!!). With many points that can go wrong in the foundation(cells->chromosomes->genes -- genotype), you don't want many points that can go wrong in the outcome(phenotype).
Of course life can (and does) beef up the genotype level with more complexity to try and ensure a rock solid phenotype (complex or not) but all factors withstanding, a simpler phenotype is easier to maintain.
Similarly, people talk about physics as a mathematical field, even though what actual entities do in the real world is the only real source of information. It isn't that the real world can be "wrong," but if a piece of evidence doesn't fit with our accumulated knowledge, that needs to be explained, not just accepted.
My understanding is that no one knows how life originated, but that doesn't stop many people from prematurely invoking the Anthropic Principal.
On complexity, logically, we cannot say that evolution has no tendency towards complexity, and also that evolution explains the complexity of modern organisms. Not that the OP was making the latter claim, but it's not an unfair assumption.
Also, your post seems to suffer from "feigned surprise" :-)
>> Also, your post seems to suffer from "feigned surprise" :-)
Ha! Good one. :) I admit, it was a bit like that.
There's a better summary from the NHM press office about what the research was really about: http://www.nhm.ac.uk/about-us/news/2014/apr/earliest-heart-a...
and it keeps getting parroted as you can sound smart.