The Inner Workings of the Executive Brain
online.wsj.com
online.wsj.com
[1] An example is "... different areas of the brain were dominant — those involved in social and emotional thinking. And the more adept strategic thinkers in the group displayed much higher levels of activity in these areas" -- What does dominant mean? How did they identify the adept strategic thinkers? It's then followed by "The potential conclusion is that people who are good at strategy are better at sensing or feeling their way through strategies, rather than relying only on logic and being rational …" -- Which is laughable and insupportable by the earlier statement.
NB: I did neuroimaging studies for my PhD and it's a tool like any other. It can be wielded skilfully and with care (leading to amazing advances) or be completely abused (leading to quackery). Without going through the experimental design it's difficult to ascertain whether the researchers were actually measuring what they thought they were measuring. In addition to this, I've noticed that academics sometimes make claims in press-releases/news that are not supported by the actual research and not even mentioned in the peer-reviewed work.
"we all "know" that tight deadlines lead to inspiration"
Do we? I've never thought that. It's always seemed straight forward that stress and reduction in avenues of potential exploration lead to less creativity, and the few moments of stress driven "eureka" lead to strong confirmation bias in the wrong direction. If this is apparently not the view of most management/executive types, no wonder business/corporate culture looks the way it currently does!It starts with: For instance, we all "know" that tight deadlines lead to inspiration. Except they often don't. Instead, they typically are counterproductive—making people less creative precisely when they need to be.
Please give a little freedom to the author to express himself!
That is, the point was reflecting on how warped the subculture of WSJ readers must be, or perhaps how warped the perceived culture among WSJ readers is. Had the author assumed that all readers already shared the idea that free breathing room is needed for inspiration, that particular sentence fragment certainly would not have appeared in the article -- therefore, kolektiv made a deduction about the author's audience.
It's certainly an interesting point to observe; I was also very surprised by that sentence in the article, because to me, the fact that freedom of pressure (and even boredom!) is helpful for inspiration seemed like one of these things that "everybody knows". [0] And apparently I was wrong ;-)
[0] Deadlines are definitely good for the perspiration part, though ;)
Edit: Any idea why this was downvoted? I've re-read it and I still think the author has slightly conflated these two things. That doesn't make the article value-less but it does help with my interpretation of it.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Crow_and_the_Pitcher
"Necessity is the mother of invention" is the version most used in English.
Did anybody read Kahnemann: Thinking fast and Slow?
Kahnemann shows how easy it is to trick our emotions and opts for cool reasoning and statical thinking. He proves that this leads to better decisions compared to allowing emotions to help in decision making. This is especially true in pressure situations. He won the Nobel Prize for this research.
That said, the key topic of the article (stress and deadlines lead to bad decisions) chimes in fine with Kahnemanns results. Emotions may help talking with the team, but certainly not with making the best decisions.
Can you train people to be more intuitive and clueful? The answer is of course yes.
I tend to agree that there's value in having subjective motivations, that can come from "instinct" (an overused and misused term in business) or emotion. Wanting to help other people is a noble and subjective goal. On the other hand, not paying attention to your data is like driving a car while blinded, on "instinct". It's a bad idea, because not seeing an obstacle doesn't mean it's not there.