Hacker News Reader

Comment by willholloway | Hacker News Reader

> I felt lots of people in New York were looking for weaknesses in what we were doing or trying to figure out who would acquire us, whereas people in the Valley were looking for ways to help us really succeed.

NYC is a weary, jaded and cynical metropolis, it's inhabitants perpetually cranky from six months of winter in their cramped, expensive, rented domiciles.

It's not your company, it's their depressed mood coupled with feelings of inferiority constantly triggered by the immense glittering wealth that surrounds them, always just out of their grasp.

View on HN

Here's another hypothesis.

It's the finance industry culture. Why?

Finance is a zero-sum game. That leads to a set of incentives where what you need to do is beat the next guy.

Tech is almost the opposite of a zero-sum games. That leads to a set of incentives where what you need to do is crack a complex problem. Cracking complex problems requires collaboration.

That sounds very correct, and is true for all the dominant industries in New York: Finance, Fashion, Law & Media.

It leads to a lot of savage energy channeling through the system, a lot of deep career dissatisfaction and a feeling that someone, somewhere is tightening the rack, with you on it.

I suspect the only real winners in the city are the landlords.

Whatever the cause, in all my time on the road I have never come across such a congregation of pessimists as I did in New York.

"Here's another hypothesis: It's the finance industry culture."

I have been on boards in the valley and in NYC, and I can see this very directly. The NY VCs were far more transactional, and more aggressively willing to drop a company and take the loss early.

Not that it's rainbows and unicorns in the valley! The VCs, after all, work for their customers (err, "LPs"). I've noticed that as the valley VCs are more and more frequently finance rather than former operating guys that they are more like this. I saw it in the dot-com boom, and guess which VCs got shellacked? Mostly the finance guys.

Nonsense. Bay Area rents are just as expensive and Chicago's winter is twenty times worse than New York, yet these area have their own unique personalities

NYC is a weary, jaded and cynical metropolis

and I wouldn't change it for the world. I far prefer living and working in an environment where I am surrounded by people from different industries and backgrounds that will question me and force me to reconsider my assumptions than a Silicon Valley world where everyone is "crushing it" until their funding suddenly dries up and everyone realises their idea was awful in the first place.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com