Traditionally (with ICC) the criticism has been that it just checks the vendor string for "GenuineIntel" instead of actually checking for feature support with CPUID. People just want the option to be able to just check just for feature support.
If you want more, use a different compiler, period. $VENDOR spends money on their compiler to support their chips, not to appease every whining, butt-hurt user on the Interwebz that thinks $BIGCO owes them something on a competing chip.