I'm getting a little tired with how out of touch people on HN seem, especially with regard to things like Facebook. Guess what: the majority of FB's user base does not care about privacy as much as you do. Even people who do care to an extent, and don't implicitly trust FB, are at least comfortable with some level of interaction and sharing on the platform. Anon login is targeted at people who are comfortable with what they share with FB, but are wary of giving their personal info to some random app they want to try.
I'd disagree too, I know many non-HN people who would be happy to switch to something else but Facebook is the incumbent.
I don't disagree with the idea of a "Anon Login" whatsoever, that is a good idea.
Maybe I'm misreading you, but it sounds like you believe that upvotes on HN allow you to infer something meaningful about what real, normal people believe. Don't make that mistake. You'll be in for a rude awakening if you do.
I don't mind this behavior/attitude of not caring because it has allowed many people to experiment with actively exfiltrating data out from behind these walled gardens through various means (some of which have been posted to HN from time to time over the years) without bothering going through OAuth and the like. And increasingly, users behind many of these walled gardens will see the false sense of security they have been offered when people/companies other than facebook can actively leverage and profiteer from "their" data. Once the data is out in the wild, whether facebook gives permission or not is moot.
They store everything even when purporting to have deleted it and privacy is contrary to their underlying core business.
Privacy and Facebook is an oxymoron
Pure auth has value to developers who want to verify a user without requiring a handshake of verifying an email address, having to manage against spam accounts, and so on. Yes it's possible to have multiple facebook accounts, but there's significantly more friction in facebook's system than in any home-rolled system you're going to come up with. While at the same time, significantly less friction from a "steps the user has to take to log into your app" point of view.
It's another developer option, one flavor among many, that developers can use to make it easier for users to log in. Given the reality that most people actually do use facebook, I think it's kind of interesting.
I can only think of LinkedIn which rather fails at the family / friends segments.