I don't think the author appreciates how difficult this is.
I think it's trivially easy. Hire some temp workers to do it.
Heck, you could put a note "We send these emails to a lot of people and many are returned to sender unopened. If you reply to this, please type the word 'reply' in the following space to make it stand out from the returned emails and grab our attention : [ ] "
Then filter those out as a priority. That could solve a lot of the problem even without a good mail filter.