I don't remember any phones having a "slide-to-unlock" before the first iPhone. If I remember most top-end phones had crappy resistive screens that required a stylus. How is that not innovation?
Windows CE - slide to unlock + touch screen without stylus introduced on Neonode N1m - 2 years before Apple "invented" it. And all this while Apple is suing HTC, Motorola and Samsung over gesture patents...
> If I remember most top-end phones had crappy resistive screens that required a stylus