So the article boils down to, middle-aged people die from smoking; all else is noise in the statistics.
So the article boils down to, middle-aged people die from smoking; all else is noise in the statistics.
While many fewer Americans are killed from alcohol than from tobacco, the absolute percentages are somewhat deceiving; whereas the lifespan of current smokers is about 12 years shorter compared to those who have never smoked, the average death from alcohol comes a whopping 29 years prematurely.
It is an apples and oranges comparison, but that's just the data we have. I tried to word this in a way that highlighted the fact that the comparison was a little dodgy.
When you say "drugs and alcohol" you should indicate the illicit drugs part of that statement is under 1%. I doubt you are correct about alcohol killing the young primarily. This article doesn't provide a lot of detail except for a broad indication it's not underage drinking that kills the most: http://www.medicinenet.com/script/main/art.asp?articlekey=17...
But how many lives are saved by these drugs? To be clear, I am totally open to this number not being nearly high enough to justify the deaths caused, and very much believe our prescription drug system should be reformed. But the fact that prescription drugs actually save lives, and are not simply causes of death, gets ignored far to much for me. I want to know the true net cost of prescription drugs (an intentionally absurd analogy would be something like airbags kill 7 people a year with no mention of how many people those airbags saved).