Looking back Python 3 came too late, didn't offer much in terms of an incentive to justify switching to it, divided the community and in the process also left other things people worry about by the wayside -- performance, packaging, better concurrency handling (no not via Tulip or Twisted).
I think, like you point out, many before they decided to sink the time into upgrading to Python 3 to get better unicode support for example, would also take the time to evaluate and go with something else altogether -- Go for example.
Sounds like a good topic for a post (or at least a link - hint, hint).
Or do you mean some other style of concurrency primitives?
PyPy is not really a good example here. It is still highly experimental, takes long time to compile, it's not compatible with quite a few libraries in normal Python, and still has all relative downsides of dynamic typing. To be frank, I don't get the point of using PyPy instead of Go.
Previously most Python libraries already use C to optimize critical components. If you can use just one language to get similar performance, why do you bother using two then?
Then well ok, the answer to "What did Python 3 bring to the Python community?" becomes "Yeah it ended up driving a lot of people away", which I am sure wasn't the intended purpose of Python 3.0
benefit(2->3 + performance benefit + maintainability) <
benefit(2->Go + performance benefit + maintainability)
The time cost of 2->3 will be less but if I know I will get better memory footprint, and faster response times I might be willing to invest some more time into it.
Or another way to look at it, once one sits down and rolls their sleeves looking to re-factor/renew/refresh the code base there is a good chance they will look around them and see what else is out there.
It's also quite an issue for COTS software - sometimes to jump forwards and clean up APIs they have to do a huge refactor, sometime even a re-write of the API. If this is troublesome enough, it's worth taking the time to look into the competition.
GIL only exists on CPython, there are other implementations.
HHVM and now PHP 5.7-dev, both with JIT - the future of PHP looks bright.
Starting a new project, we would choose PHP, Node.js or Go according to the requirements.
But you might actually not like to hear Node's V8 engine is between 50 and 150 times faster than PHP in synthetic benchmarks, and about 20 times faster in more diversified applications (as long as they don't sit an eternity blocking waiting on a DB call which is the way people did web apps 10 years ago). That's 2000% faster than PHP, just so we use the same units here.
I'm very happy PHP is getting faster and all, but just don't juxtapose it next to JS engines (which the article talks about), let alone something more serious like the JVM, because the "bright future" of PHP starts looking quite dim in comparison.
Check out an independent benchmark for comparision: http://www.techempower.com/benchmarks/#section=data-r9&hw=i7...
PyPy is good. I wish there was more moment and more _pull_ for it from the main Python team. I feel the big push for the last 3-4 years should have been for PyPy (or performance and tooling in general).
EDIT:
To expand, I remember feeling so excited during the PyCon-s in Chicago and then Atlanta. Unladen Swallow was making some progress but PyPy was fantastic, great speed improvements. Everyone looked in awe at you guys, and your presentations. We talked about STM and all the great things.
And then...Guido announced in a rather annoyed tone how PyPy will never be a part of main Python distro and that's that. "Stop dreaming folks". And that made me pretty disappointed.
Then the drumbeat for Python 3.0 started. Unicode, unicode, unicode... it got louder and louder.
The wall of shame for "incompatible" libraries that were not being ported to Python 3.0. Lots of how to migrate and to Python 3 talks. Lots of oh look at the great view iterators.
Things that would make me get off my seat and start porting to Python 3 would be: greenlet integration for low memory, concurrency green threads (gevent and eventlet). Great CPU speed improvement with included PyPy. Notice what is not on the list -- unicode, view iterators and renaming Queue module to queue. Sorry if I am being too sarcastic here, it is because I am bitter about it.
It is also important to realize that Python 2.0 is just very good that it becomes hard for Python 3.0 to beat it. There were not big hairy warts that just bothered me about it. So it isn't that Python 3.0 is bad, it is not, it is just not better enough Python 2.0.
Now I agree with you having PyPy's performance improvements in the main implementation would be awesome, and PyPy itself is quite impressive. If they could get both NumPy running on PyPy and support Python 3's changes, it would keep Python a strong competitor for the foreseeable future.
And to your last point, I entirely agree Python 2.0 had so many strengths that it's really hard to improve upon it. Though I think that it's unicode support was the big hairy wart.
Perhaps you are right. My bitterness was coming through. It no t just that he said but how he said it.
In a way Python 3.0 also broke compatibility, for what I think, are not very good reasons. Some of that code was from people/companies who have adopted and used Python and made it popular. They are now living on a dead-end maintenance only branch.
None of those things make me want to get up roll up my sleeves and say "I can't wait to dig in and make my code compatible with 3.4". If I woke up tomorrow and someone would have magically done that for me and tested it, yeah great. I would buy them a beer. But that is about it. I have 0 incentive today to upgrade.
Code works very well now just using unicode support from Python 2 and print as a statement + other warts.