China’s Property Bubble Has Already Popped, Report Says
blogs.wsj.com
blogs.wsj.com
-5×5 office cubicle for every man/woman/child in China
-New Residential real estate accounts for 15% of GDP
-60% of GDP is towards fixed asset investment
-Buyers in China purchased 44% more residential space than they did in 2008
-Dubai during its peak had 240 sq. Mtrs/1million dollars in GDP. China has 4x that.
-Lending went up 95% yoy 2009-2008 and up 60% through 2010
-Perpetual China Bull – Goldman is forecasting a 10-20% decline in housing prices in 2011.
-Chinese vacancy rates are accepted to be unusually high but exact numbers are extremely hard to find. The Chinese investors essentially treat real estate investing as investing in Gold without even bothering to rent them out because of the unusually low rents. http://finance.fortune.cnn.com/2010/11/17/chanos-vs-china/
I also disagree with some of Chanos' points regarding rent. At least in Beijing, rent is quite expensive, and unaffordable for most Chinese. Unmarried people live with multiple roommates in places that, to the American eye, look like slums. Rents in Beijing went up an average of 20% last year (although we talked my landlord down to 10%, I think). Now it might be that rents as a proportion of the owner's income is not worth the hassle, thay could very well be. But rents in Beijing are not affordable.
Regarding vacancies, the common wisdom among expats in Beijing is that the reason is that people consider apartments to lose value if it is rented. That might be related to the reputation of Chinese renters; I have heard from a number of sources that renters in China often trash the place, although I have no way to verify that.
Anyway, if the point of the parent post is to say that this article is incorrect because some cried wolf two years ago, I strongly disagree. 20% rent increase per year (or even 10%) is not sustainable. Nor is that exponential curve in the article sustainable. The crash may or may not have happened, and may or may not happen in the future, but the current situation cannot continue forever.
We'd be happy in Europe with 3% GDP growth, and I'm sure the US wouldn't be unhappy about that too.
China's 15 Trillion pump: http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2013-11-25/chart-day-how-china...
The other problem is that local governments in China are massively overextended with vast outstanding debts, mostly backed by property. Chinese local officials are routinely rotated between regions, so they have little long term commitment to the area they run and are only interested in results during their tenure. This has lead to a generation of highly short-term management decisions, ramping up debt to fund prestige projects, with chronic lack of long term planning or infrastructure investment. Much of Chinese domestic driven growth is spending wasted on white elephant construction projects. When those turn out to be worthless, the entire Chinese domestic economy will crash.
A third issue is that up to half of the populations of Chinese cities are technically migrant labour and, even if they've lived in the city for generations, they are technically not residents and have no claim on local services or any welfare support and no pensions. When the bubble bursts they'll be left with nothing. Either the flow of labour from the countryside to the cities will reverse, or the system will break.
Well unless you count 'current market valuations' for all that empty real estate, that is smirks
A country can afford, or at least isn't hurt that badly by, low birth rates when those who are born don't have to support (or at least not fully) the elderly - I don't think it's reasonable to put China on one line with the other countries you mention.
It's like smirking at the gambling industry, except with very respectable and influential people pushing it.
The short term problem is the number of urban workers is already growing faster than the number of urban jobs, so making even more unemployed people is not exactly a net gain.
When one child came in, the proportion of children to workers suddenly dropped. That was very useful for productivity, as people were working not caring for children.
The other side of that coin is the age cliff.
This is not a decline in population, so much as a change in the proportion of workers to old people. Note that because of the nature of work, 50 year olds in China are often at the end of their practical working life, because the work is hard and they are disabled.
The problem is similar to the baby boomers in America, suddenly, a smaller number of workers must support larger number of non-working old. However, it is much worse because the shift in birth rates was much sharper.
This is a problem for the next decade or so. However, like all these things, it does not necessarily mean the apocalypse. China has built up great wealth and interests overseas, and the government (which will end up carrying much of this cost) controls many of these interests. You would be looking at a shift from an economy that primarily produces, to an economy that primarily consumes, like the US.
They do get pensions now...well, we have to make pension payments at least (I'm considered a migrant worker, though the foreigner kind).
Goodness gracious, aren't we trusting of predictions of the scope of economic downturns. People aren't very good at predicting such things, and to be clear, I fully mean that in both directions, not that people always under-predict. I don't know about "worst case" but a very plausible scenario is "revolution in China", and whatever long term effects that may have in the short term it would be a massive, globe-spanning economic contraction. That's at least in the single-digit percentages of probability.
I think there's a lot of hanky-panky going on in the books over there, and once there's no longer enough credit to cover over the problems, the full depth of the rot is likely to surprise everyone. (Or at least everyone who has somehow made it to 2014 trusting strong centralized Communist governments to be truthful about their economic health, but, alas, that still seems to be a lot of people. [1]) Just what is making it out of the firewall alone is enough to give me the heebie-jeebies and I seriously doubt I'm getting even the tip of the iceberg.
[1]: Before anybody says it, personally I think the US government has also taken some pretty serious steps into deceptive reporting of economic health itself in the past several years.
How? They invest 60% of a loan in building a property, they finish it in bad quality and put 40% in their own pocket. The bank takes the building to get their money back...
It seems to be a regular case in China, off course something's going to pop after a while.
Also that's an average. This means there must be plenty of regions where property prices have actually dropped. That's new.
It's a bitter pill to swallow, but we may well be shielded from this nascent catastrophe because of China's disregard for human life.
But I stand by the comment none the less. China has set its own precedent, and I see little reason to predict they will break with tradition.
A crash will happen sometime in the future, the only question is about timing.
By far the greatest force for sobriety was the New York Times. Under the guidance of the veteran Alexander Dana Noyes, its financial page was all but immune to the blandishments of the New Era. A regular reader could not doubt that a day of reckoning was expected. Also, on several occasions it reported, much too prematurely, that the day of reckoning had arrived.
Indeed the temporary breaks in the market which preceded the crash were a serious trial for those who had declined fantasy. Early in 1928, in June, in December, and in Februrary and March of 1929 it seemed that the end had come. On various of these occasions the [New York] Times happily reported the return to reality. And then the market took flight again. Only a durable sense of doom could survive such discouragement. The time was coming when the optimists would reap a rich harvest of discredit. But is has long since been forgotten that for many months those who resisted reassurance were similarly, if less permantently, discredited. To say that the Times, when the real crash came, reported the event with jubilation would be an exaggeration. Nevertheless, it coverted it with an unmistakable absence of sorrow
- John Kenneth Galbraith, "The Great Crash 1929" http://www.amazon.com/Great-Crash-1929-Kenneth-Galbraith/dp/...