Computer gaming is a hugely important industry, and the reason that we even have powerful computers and graphics cards today.
You need to defend your opinion a bit more if you want it treated as anything other than that, an opinion.
Computer gaming is a hugely important industry, and the reason that we even have powerful computers and graphics cards today.
You need to defend your opinion a bit more if you want it treated as anything other than that, an opinion.
I'm not sure if I'm reading this correctly, but this seems like a strange false dilemma. Kids shouldn't only play games, but there's nothing wrong with letting your kids play them in moderation. It certainly doesn't make you a bad parent, quite the opposite. Many games can improve critical thinking ability. I discovered programming as a kid out a desire to make games. If I hadn't been allowed to play them, I wouldn't be where I am today. Good parents should let their kids play games.
The conversation is more complicated than you realize.
At level 1, there exist many parents who, for whatever reason, purchase gadgets for their kids as a means of distraction. Video games, cell phones, etc. This is generally a result of poor decision-making and life circumstance. (Mother died and dad is trying to pick up the slack; hospital bills crippled their finances and they're exhausted after coming home from their third job; work is more important, they weren't really interested in having kids anyways; etc.) Really, this should be level 0, but the exact reason isn't relevant.
At level 2 is people like ausjke, who look at this and see a lot of kids who are utterly absorbed and addicted. They respond to this by swinging the pendulum as far as possible to the other side. Don't be like those kids; they make their parents look bad. To an extent, they have a point: LED screens are very captivating, no matter what's playing on them. But at the end of the day, it's an overreaction.
At level 3, you have angersock, who can see as far down as level 1 and blames the parents. They're not wrong, per se, because the issue at hand is at level 2. If parents paid more attention, then the kids would play in moderation rather than excessively. It tends to be unheard because people at level 2, like ausjke, are pretty self-righteous about how they themselves have parented or were parented.
But as ausjke says, there is a surprisingly good analogy here in drugs. That is, the problem with drugs has nothing to do with drugs and everything to do with societal demonization, power struggles between classes, poor legislation, and economic consequences. He says we ought to blame the drug dealers, but he never asks where they get the drugs and more importantly why they bother at all.
It's a conversation that's been tread over and over and over again. It's not a false dilemma; it's a call-and-response routine.
All that said, there is simply too much complexity wrapped up in the "Games are evil!" sentiment to really do much than call back with the rote "But but but the parental responsibility!".
Why are kids not playing outside--is it because of cookie-cutter suburbs and helicopter parents and the terrorists and kidnappers? Why don't parents have enough time to spend on their kids--is it the long hours at work to support a consumerist and debt-ridden lifestyle? Why is it even important for kids to have access to phones or video games?
These are all interesting questions somewhat fundamental to the issue, and unfortunately they'll never be answered to anyone's satisfaction.
You can have interesting conversations about this stuff; you just can't have it with people who aren't ready to move past the routine.
one reason there are less boys in college than girls, guess what, games. I actually read this somewhere.
My piano teacher, whose two kids are still at home playing games, at their 20s.
You don't just blame drug abusers, you do also blame the drug dealers. In _most_ cases, game designers are doing the same thing as a drug dealer who sells the drug, wearing an IT hat. Parenting can not do this alone when gaming is now becoming a culture/fashion/addictive, due to our genius developers.
Games are a part of culture, just like music is. Music serves no intrinsic utilitarian purpose. You wouldn't want to cut a person of culture any less you would want a person to never listen to music.
Of course, anything in excess tends to be bad. And some games are engineered in diabolical ways and only live to make money. But games in an of itself are a natural and important part of a normal human beings life. And in this generation, computer games are.
As parents we're doing our best, I'm just saying gaming is in the most part, a bad thing, I'm not saying every game is bad, as some drugs are useful for medical reasons too.
it's a shame to compare most games to music and painting, that does not make the game industry looks artistic in any way. it's more in the ballpark of alcohol, cigars and drugs, yes they're all popular, same as games, but they do not get the positive images in the society, games should be treated the same. Games do not deserve anything more positive than drugs, again, for the most part in general.
I am fine to be down voted to zero, though I hope some of you game developers know that, there are other ways to make a living than being a game developer.
I'm interested in knowing, in general, how games help kids, teenagers, even adults to be a better person to the society, by reading more, working harder, be less voilent, and staying touch with the real world? There are indeed some good games, again for the most part, they're the opposite.