My take at the time was that McPherson wasn't making a causal or even correlative claim: just showing that this similar social structure appeared at the same time in two completely distinct situations. Nothing more than that. Which ends up being _interesting_, but not something that you can directly _use_ in any day-to-day way. That said, I do think the 'modular form' makes a lot of sense, and it has impacted some of my thinking. For a recent variant of this, you may enjoy Galloway's criticism of the OOO people. He draws a sort of similar conceptual schema with regards to {Ford,Taylor}ism's modularity and OOP, as well as the anti-humanism of OOO.
Then again, re-reading just now:
> In short, I suggest that these two moments are deeply interdependent.
Sooooo maybe that assessment was off. I'll have to give this another read. I guess I'm currently in agreement with your 'summary' link.
> My take is her sourcing of Eric S. Raymond and his writings to be really interesting.
Yeah. I mean, it's the logical place to go. And if you want to talk about the intersection of programming and race, well, esr is one of the more embarrassing sources you can pull up. She didn't touch on any of that, though, which I was pretty surprised about.
> I'd be highly interested for a socio-literary critical analysis of code
I'll take only the first half of this sentence to plug my own project: set up an email reminder to check out http://metaphysics.io, which I recently purchased for this express purpose. I'm still working out exactly what the project is, but I have four initial essays that I've drafted up so far. I think I'm going to release them as "issues", rather than one at a time like blog posts. Three of them are explicitly computer science related and one is not. The first issue deals mostly with affect theory, because I've been enamored with it lately.
You may want to check out what Kevin Brock has been doing lately around the intersection of rhetoric and code. There are other people who touch on this from time to time too, one of the most recent: https://www.destroyallsoftware.com/blog/2014/tdd-straw-men-a...
> whether the debate/adoption of new frameworks/languages/paradigms (Go, Ember.js, Rust, Responsive Design) is a new form of elitism and/or marketing for software developers as a consumer class.
This idea is super interesting. I want to describe it as much more... cynical than what I think, but it may in fact be true.
> Also the shift from centralized servers to a more distributed programming model mirror the fragmentary nature, autonomous organizing of modern living
I will most certainly be writing some thoughts about this in the future. I almost can see a parallel to McPhereson: two modes of organization, springing up in the same time and place.