> I'd recommend simply avoiding a bad diet (mostly just eat a diversity of foods) then you will already be getting all the vitamins/nutrients/etc you need while avoiding getting too much of anything that is bad for you.
A diversity of foods doesn't mean much.
Fish oil is commonly recommended for good reasons. The amount of Omega 3 in the American diet is insanely low, mostly due to the lack of sea food in the average American diet (Seafood being one of the more plentiful sources of Omega 3).
In addition to that, the amount of Omega 6 in the average American's diet is sky high. There are potential problems when the Omega3/Omega6 ratio in a diet is too far in favor of Omega 6, these problems are what Fish Oil is theorized to help with.
On a more general note, many supplements can help with a variety of problems. While I'd say most supplements are worthless, there are quite a few that are not.
If you properly take melatonin, it will help with your sleep. (Don't take the huge doses most people do, 300mcg will suffice, overdosing will hurt your sleep after awhile!)
l-Theanine greatly reduces the side effects of caffeine and helps it work longer. Flat out, less anxiety, less jitters, and a large increase in focus.
Creatine flat out helps all around with physical performance, and may help out with some mental performance as well. There are dozens upon dozens of studies showing creatine's effectiveness.
Heck there are supplements out there that work as treatment for diabetes by controlling blood glucose levels, and by control, I mean "take this supplement, blood glucose levels drop".
The multi-vitamin sold at your local pharmacy? Yeah likely useless (or even worse), assuming it has any active ingredients in it at all.
But well researched supplements from reputable companies that have independent third party audits done on their production lines?
Pretty damn useful.