Air Force Spending $60 Million for SpaceX U.S. Launches
bloomberg.com
bloomberg.com
Each launch will probably cost far more until their grasshopper system gets used.
"Musk, 42, ranked 133rd on the Bloomberg Billionaires Index with a net worth of $9.2 billion as of May 13." Wow.
"Davis said the Air Force estimates that SpaceX will be certified to receive contracts no later than May 2015."
This Senate hearing explains some of the costs: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IWVZYKGTenE
5+ certified quick turn around launches would be at least several years away.
At some point, some launch customer will observe that there have been N test launches of reused stages without incident, and thus it's worth buying a launch on one at a lower price. Since SpaceX is making money launching stuff anyway, they can take their time getting to whatever number N turns out to be.
The legs and computers are probably not too much more than a bolt-on kit that adds some weight to the rocket, the rocket will still preform as usual and the test is practically free (verses actually testing a new rocket design like other vertical landing rockets have tried).
They've already done it twice (once without the legs and once with) while getting paid to launch payloads. The experimental part doesn't come into play until after the first stage has done its primary job, so there's no additional risk to the customer.
This is why I think ongoing comparisons to the Shuttle and other reusable systems are completely wrong. Previous attempts have all been based on much more complicated and expensive vehicles that were expected to compensate by being reused. SpaceX is taking a system that's already one of the cheapest in the business (if not the cheapest?) and making some minor changes to reuse it and make it even cheaper.
NASA had to reuse the Shuttle on its second flight ever. SpaceX can keep testing Falcon 9R for as long as customers are willing to pay for launches at their current prices, which looks to be quite a long time.
It seems like such a simple solution to the cost problem (with the attachable reusable legs on existing flights) but I'm amazed that no other rocket company has done it until now, congratulations SpaceX.
I guess it was mostly because of the rocket technology (relighting an engine), the new materials (probably carbon fiber legs), and the new/cheap/lightweight computer technologies available today.
Hopefully there will be some great videos/pictures from the next test which will land closer to land: http://spaceflightnow.com/tracking/index.html http://www.orbcomm.com/networks/og2-launch
I'd say the odds are good for SpaceX, as it's a much easier problem (no thermal protection system, the engines are a lot less fragile, nothing is being dunked in salt water), but we'll have to see how it really works out.
As for why it hasn't been tried before, it seems like the space industry is afraid of doing anything that is somehow short of what's seen as optimal. Rockets are optimized for fuel use by pushing engines and weight to the limit, which is odd because the fuel isn't really expensive. If you're going to cut down on that in the service of another goal like reusability, it seems like they want some huge payoff in exchange. Thus the shuttle ended up as a fancy spaceplane that could bring entire satellites back from orbit, and Rotary Rocket, DC-X, and X-33 were all shooting for single-stage-to-orbit. I don't know how much technology SpaceX is bringing in versus just an attitude that it's OK to be suboptimal, that it's OK to lose payload to reusability, that it's OK to work incrementally and keep throwing away some of your hardware, etc.
As I recall, a normal Falcon 9 launch is $60 million, and they estimate something like a $30 million premium for Air Force work due to the extra certification required.
I have no real idea what Falcon 9R (reusable) launches will cost, and I'd hazard that SpaceX only has a rough idea for the moment, until they can actually see how the rockets withstand multiple launches. But the cool thing about their reusable program is that they're building it on top of a sustainable, economic conventional program, so they can take it slow and incrementally.
Regarding Musk's net worth, a lot of that is tied up in stock of somewhat questionable value. He owns about a quarter of Tesla, for example, and with a current market cap of $23 billion, that'll account for around 2/3rds of his total net worth. Tesla isn't necessarily overvalued, but the stock value is heavily based on enormous future success, and unforeseen circumstances could bring it down in a way that a more established company might withstand. (To put it in perspective, Tesla is worth about half of what GM is worth, even though GM sells literally 100 times more cars. Again, it could very well be justified based on future performance, but it's uncertain.)
The Delta IV and Atlas V have overlapping use cases. The Russian engine (RD-180) is only used in the Atlas V. So it would seem that they could shift to the Delta IV once the stockpile runs out.
They also have the blueprints and specs for the RD-180. It would take a lot of time and money to ramp up production, but not as much as if they were building a new engine from scratch.
That said, I do agree that the US would probably be screwed (in the wallet) without SpaceX.