The breakdown of the OKCupid process has these two comments about illustrations:
1. Illustration of smiling high confidence person draws you in.
2. The illustration feels a bit flat and 'uncanny-valley-ish.' it leaves an
impersonal impression, but that might be the intent (i.e. you get the
personal stuff when you log in)
Would you be surprised to learn that these comments are about the same illustration? I was. I clicked back and forth 4-5 times to make sure I was not missing something. A lot of the comments made it seem like I was listening to Foamy the Squirrel give stream of consciousness impressions as he signed up for online dating.