* It only works on chrome, obviously, because it's a chrome extension. That means you will continue to get crappy results on all your other browsers and devices.
* It modifies the links after you load the page so you see them disappear which can be disorienting. I really don't want those search results even making it into the DOM.
* As of now I'm not able to even edit my list (the options menu item is grayed out) and I have no idea why. The quality of the extension is poor at best.
* It has zero intelligence. What would be ideal is that I could subscribe to a blocklist of well known content farms and allow crowdsourcing to maintain and add to that list.
The clear message from Google is that it doesn't really want to support or encourage wholesale blocking of any domains. Google would prefer to be the entity that makes that decision for you, and since these content farms make Google a lot of money don't hold your breath that they're going to start cracking down in a serious way anytime soon.
It would get harder for Google to crawl new content on the internet because they'd be filtering through progressively more clever and aggressive farms to find real pages. I'm sure is already the case, but aggressive blocking would provoke farms into getting worse.
When Google created Adsense it built an ecosystem. While other search engines lost users as soon as they clicked on a link, Google had a fairly high percentage chance that user still made them money.
I don't know if the future looks much better. What Larry Page is saying that instead of display a link of Stack Overflow results he would like to scrape the answer to the query in a way the user never has to go there. The way they will make money from advertising with that model looks even worse.
You might be on to something here with censoring as a service
It would actually be pretty simple. A search bar. If you search doesn't exist, you're prompted to create a new page and add in whatever links you've found. Users could also vote to merge searches, etc.
You'd need some major fraud detection of course but I think it would be possible.
Anyone interested in working on that?
[1] http://userscripts.org/scripts/show/95205 (looks userscripts.org is down right now)
However google actually rewards that.
http://webmasters.stackexchange.com/questions/53703/choosing...
Check several competitive markets in bigger cities. Examples: City Dentist, City Personal Injury Attorney, City Chiropractor. For many the top 3 - 5 are EMDs.
Google just reduced the weight of EMDs, so if thin or spammy content and all they have going for them is the EMD, they won't rank. But an EMD with good content and marketing still ranks well in local.
Adwords is also excellent, but the skill to use it is not well distributed. Advertisers have more obvious incentives and measurement metrics (return on total ad spent / return on investment) than hobbyists do.