The Intimacy of Crowds
aeon.co
aeon.co
The most popular theory? This is the first time i've ever heard of it.
The most popular theory i heard was that a lot of people realised that they could loot some shops without getting caught. The more people who joined in the looting, the thinner the police were stretched, and the safer it was to join in.
Look at the Watts riots in the 60's. I think everyone, at this vantage point in time, believes that was caused by the deplorable conditions there and the state of civil rights for blacks, and not because people wanted stuff for free.
The 2007 financial crisis had far ranging effects, and some of them take a while to percolate down and cause problems. My city is next door to a poorer one, and the first thing I thought of was, eventually, the crime in my neighborhood would go up. It took 3 years, but it happened.
Which was ironic, because the shops looted were almost all in the rioters' neighbourhoods, and many of them will have been owned, outright or as franchises, by local people.
I don't know much about the Watts riots, but my impression is that they were quite different. There, most of the participants were attacking the police or any white people they came across, rather than looting their own neighbourhood. The Broadwater Farm and poll tax riots in London were the same - battles between the authorities and people angry at the authorities. The 2011 riots were quite different.
I find this quotation in the article the most interesting:
"‘What the rioters appeared to be seeking was fuller participation in the social order and the material benefits enjoyed by the majority of American citizens,’ it concluded. ‘Rather than rejecting the American system, they were anxious to obtain a place for themselves in it.’"
We see this time and again: demonstration and revolt come from those who have something to gain (or lose), not from the truly wretched. From the French revolution to the 60s in Europe and the USA, to Korea in the 80s/90s to Venezuela today.
Yet my kid was still told in school this year that the French revolution was the peasants rising up. It's not like that theory is believed by any academics but still it hasn't filtered down to school.
Likewise, as this article describes it, the idea of "the madness of crowds" is well established in the popular mind, even though it's thoroughly discredited by academic research.
Yet policy is made based on crazy beliefs. I am still a fan of democracy, but when the kids are fed a rasher of discredited bullshit in high school it's hard to see how it can function.
> social psychologist Gustave Le Bon, tried to explain crowd behaviour as a paralysis of the brain; hypnotised by the group, the individual becomes the slave of unconscious impulses. ‘He is no longer himself, but has become an automaton who has ceased to be guided by his will,’ he wrote in 1895. ‘Isolated, he may be a cultivated individual; in a crowd, he is a barbarian… a grain of sand amid other grains of sand, which the wind stirs up at will.’
One could just as easily say that individual behavior is paralysis of the brain, hypnotized by the culture.
If someone is more 'cultivated' as an individual, it's simply because he's had much more practice in that form- a group of people who act as one is not only possible, and quite impressive, but it takes work- willpower and practice.
This kind of article, making all kinds of guesses based on little bits of psychology research, and presenting them as facts...
This is supposed to be an illuminated tech community, so I'll say it straight: When psychology meets up with the other sciences in the form of ai research, bs like this will finally be recognized as grossly oversimplistic garbage.
I give the article a C-minus: trying to sound knowledgeable without promoting much useful information.
___
I wonder how this fits into a scene [1] that happened last week in Sao Paulo when bus drivers started striking and the metro became overcrowded. It wasn't due to a crisis, per se, and the metro didn't break down but sensibility surely went out the window.
My own assessment of the video below is that no one saw themselves as part of a crowd/group, but as individuals.
1 - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CXycKeyDKXk (btw, I shared this as an 'aside' on HN a few days ago)
> men aggressed more than women in the individuated condition, but this difference was eliminated in the deindividuated condition.
scientists get on this shit or I will come to your house and burn your degrees