Of course votes reflect agreement / disagreement. What else can they realistically reflect?
Of course votes reflect agreement / disagreement. What else can they realistically reflect?
The end result is an ever increasing alignment of 'group-think' where popular opinions are boosted and differing opinions are hidden.
Up/down voters just need to take a second and consider what they're voting for. If it's just because they agree, then don't. If they agree and they've learned something new, then do. If they disagree and but they think the arguments are well presented or they've learned something new, upvote.
Down voting should be reserved only for inappropriate comments, not disagreement.
But back to my main point: When everything is majority rules, with no checks and balances, society collapses into mob rule. Why would it be any different with upvote/downvote?
We're not going to solve this by asking users to think before they click downvote. We should consider removing the upvote/downvote altogether.