That's a bit how I view "keto". If you read /r/keto people seems to discover the golden diet and way of living. It's cool that it works for them but do you really need a restrictive diet (I would even say "socially restrictive diet") when the first I want to scream to Americans is "just eat smaller portions FFS!".
If you read any subreddit people seems to discover the golden diet and way of living. You have to remember theyre just strangers on the internet and you have no reason to believe them over doctors. If there was actually a way proved to result in long-term weight loss doctors would be using it, period.
Not everyone wants to "live" on Soylent. But it makes a damn good and fast meal replacement for those times when you want more calories and don't have the time to cook / eat a meal. E.g. bodybuilders who need to eat at caloric surplus to gain muscle.