Why not just use the IRC?
Our take, is that topic-based discussions are of interest to a lot of less-technical folks, too. For them, something like Chapp is easier.
Edit: in fact, Chapp itself could be built on top of IRC and retain all of its current functionality. You'll also gain a very well battle tested protocol and software tools.
I suppose that’s part of why we’re doing this. We don’t know quite where we’ll end up, but do think there’s room for something in between IRC and more common social networks.
Chapp is still very early on—hence the bugs and rough edges. That said, we’re glad to have a working prototype in place, so we can muck about, and explore where it can be pushed.