Its not about whether those individual attributes existed already.
Samsung blatantly copied apple product designs, from the physical appearance of the device, to the design of the packaging right down to the design of the chargers and cables.
This is not speculation, it's fact.
I don't deny that most modern smartphones, including the iPhone, look vaguely similar to that LG. No way you would confuse them for the same product though.
Now look at this image: http://i.imgur.com/TmUj2.jpg
This isn't some case of "oh but Apple's design is obvious how can it not be the same?"
This is Samsung's business model.
Motorola RAZR (copied Samesung Blade) - even the name is a pun on the fact that its a copy (hint: razor blade)
Blackberry (copied as Samsung BlackJack) - again the even the name is a ridiculous rip off. This one went to court and funnily enough RIM won.
Samsung Innov8 (copied from Nokia N96)
In 2012 Samsung released their Chromebox, which copies the circular cover on the 2 year old MacMini. The MacMini has it there to allow RAM upgrades. The ChromeBox has no reason for it, besides copying the MacMini design.
In their advertising they have a history of either reproducing Apple ads (e.g. the way a phone and the earbuds are arranged). In one case, they literally photoshopped the iOS Google Maps app onto their own device.
Their "iRemote Control 4" is a ridiculously blatant copy of the iPhone 4
Do a quick search for "Dyson Samsung clone"
There is no question that Samsung copies it's competitors designs, packaging and advertising. Apple was granted a design patent and used that in its fight with Samsung.
Show me a case where Apple has used its design patent against a competitor that is not obviously trying to blatantly copy their devices?