“The real problem with revenue sharing is that it is an undisclosed, under-the-table payment from the broker to the adviser,” said Professor Bullard, though he noted that not all arrangements were conflict-ridden.
The divergent standards between those - like me - who serve companies and sophisticated investors, and those who serve unsophisticated Main Street clients is startling. To me, it would be preposterous to not be fiduciarilly bound to a retained client. But apparently this is business-as-usual for retirement advisors. Similarly, I face liability if I do not disclose any related fees or payments to all parties following a transaction. But retail financial advisors see those agreements as trade secrets.
There may be a good argument for obscuring this information from unsophisticated parties. I think the abundance of information available to be mis-interpreted by unsophisticated retail investors is part of the problem. But I haven't heard the brokers articulate it.
As for fiduciary obligation, I cannot understand the present situation. But I also believe that banks should be partnerships, where at the end of the capital structure are the partners' personal assets. Perhaps I'm just old world.