Isn't it implied and understood that I can only speak for myself and from my own perspective? I think my post was littered liberally enough with words like 'personally' and 'I feel' that it's understood I'm not trying to speak in absolutes. So, would you rather I didn't raise any questions about the relative merits of the code simply because there may be people who find it useful? I'm certainly not arguing that no one will find it useful, I'm simply saying that I don't like it and giving the reasons why I think so. If you didn't want people to discuss the relative merits of the code, why did you post it?
EDIT: Ah, you elided what the above is a rebuttal of, which is good because that brings the discussion back to the actual code in question.
There are a ton of little idiomatic extensions to Ruby that are immensely useful, SymbolToProc being a very good example. The presence of so many of them is one of the great things about Rails. So, I'm not arguing against such things as a whole, as you imply I am. I'm simply saying that #returning in particular is one that I have problems with.
Nor am I saying that making things less readable for the uninitiated is a sufficient motivation to bar use of such things. However, this particular idiom gives you so little that I feel what you gain from it does not outweigh the cost of introducing it. So, I do feel that the idiom doesn't add any value, and for that reason there is a cost associated with its use.
It doesn't save you any code, and it's more complicated than the code it replaces, which is why I am puzzled that you find it easier to understand. It makes things wordier with a block invocation when a simple assignment will suffice. Ostensibly, assignment is a much 'lower level' mechanism than invoking a method with a block.
I readily admit, though, that if you find it easier to read then there's no argument I can make, because it works for you. Similarly, though, I can state that it is not easier to read for me. So, I guess we just have to agree to disagree on the basis that our brains work differently =)