The mainstream press, on the other hand, is shrinking every month.
The current definition of notability is like Newtonian physics. It's useful, but must eventually be replaced by a more nuanced model.
The mainstream press, on the other hand, is shrinking every month.
The current definition of notability is like Newtonian physics. It's useful, but must eventually be replaced by a more nuanced model.
There are more growth metrics behind the most visible one - number of articles, which is displayed on the main page.
http://stats.wikimedia.org/EN/ChartsWikipediaEN.htm
Compare charts "New articles per day" vs. "Edits per article". Former has declined during last two years, but latter has increased significantly.
New articles per day average was 171 in 2007, 149 in 2009. Edits per article was 51 in 2007, 65 in 2009. Bytes per article (=quality) is also growing (http://stats.wikimedia.org/EN/TablesArticlesBytesPerArticle....).
These tell a different story. Wikipedia's growth isn't just in the number of new articles anymore.
I personally would jettison 'notability' for 'usefulness', and improve the procedures for allowing 'self-published' material -- even up to original research and the testimony of primary sources -- to provide Wikipedia content, as long as it's true.
Yes, that's harder than just deferring to traditional high-reputation news and academic publishers. But those publishers are retreating, while the need for reference information is growing, and this problem needs the boldness of the wiki-model, even as Wikipedia has become squeamish about such experimentalism.
Whether your app dies in obscurity or explodes in popularity, if Wikipedia could collect true and useful info about it, why exert extra effort to exclude or erase that info?
If there's a topic that only a dozen people in the world (currently) care about, but one or two of them are willing and able to write neutral, reference-style articles about that topic that will be of interest to the next dozen people, why exile that work elsehwere because of traditional standards of 'notability' based on the idea of limited staff time and print-page column-inches?
For example the article on UFO's (or Cold Fusion) can have a section by proponents, and a section by dis-ponents (if that's a word).
The section by proponents can say: This section was written by people who believe foo bar.
The other section can say: This was written by people who believe that foo bar is not true.
How do you know which to believe? Well you don't. All you know is the source. And that, I think, is enough. Each reader can attempt to authenticate the source on his own (perhaps by perusing articles about the source).
There are many topics where it's not possible to get full sites for them.
But I'm not actually expecting wikipedia to change - I gave up on them about a year ago.
Would this "debate" style extend to every contentious issue? Will the article on Theodore Roosevelt have to be interrupted by a pro-con debate on whether Theodore Roosevelt was actually a woman, if someone decides to suggest that he was? How many other crazy theories can we raise before the article becomes totally unreadable?
http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/foundation/f/f6/WMF_Mi...