The case against organic food does not stand up
guardian.co.uk
guardian.co.uk
And pardon me for paranoia, but I also know that the Monsantos and Cargills of the world spend mega-bucks lobbying against organics in the halls of government. But one must ultimately set such suspicions aside and deal with the report upon its own merits.
Meta-studies are damn hard to do and get right. But they are next to worthless if there is an agenda behind the study, which this article appears to imply.
The problem is that we're all losers if we're wrong about organics and we get lower yields from land, this will ultimately reduce food security, increase food costs and increase prices for everyone - rich and poor alike. I think you also assume that those who are for organics (which in its own right is becoming a significant business) don't have an agenda of their own to encourage consumers to pay a premium for their product.
I make no such assumption about organic producers not wanting to keep prices high, because this is not really a problem. The market will set the price of organics to be appropriate and sustainable regardless of any nefarious plot by organic producers to keep prices high.
Also, you make in incorrect correlation between organic farming and low yield. That is a myth (http://www.foodfirst.org/node/1778). Organic farming does not equal low yield. The high yield of today's crops does not come from chemical fertilizer, but from producing high-yield varietals via selective breeding, something that is completely in keeping with organic farming methods.
Another interesting article here: http://www.boston.com/bostonglobe/ideas/articles/2008/03/16/...
I note the irony of citing Rachel Carson's Silent in the article you linked to what with her assertions debunked in subsequent years not to mention the resulting increase in deaths from malaria - at least some of which was preventable.
Additional thoughts here: http://www.reason.com/blog/show/122504.html
The only likely way it would increase the cost non-organic is if governments started to force farmers to pay for the 'externalities' (i.e. environmental cost) of their farming methods. But we wouldn't be 'all losers' in this either. It would simply be transfer of costs from people who are essentially mooching off the system (i.e. me by using cheap non-organic food) to the beneficiaries of a cleaner environment (all of us).
Adding arbitrary production constraints tend to add costs - and in the case of "organic". From what I've been reading, organics cost more to control - so either you need more land or you need more inputs - labor or additives. If you go the land route, more limited land drives up cost of the cost of the underlying capital required for everyone - given that land is also an important input at the moment for general farming. Of course, I think consumers would be best served whether buying organic or regular if the governments of the world would abandon farming subsidies that greatly distort markets - but dare to dream.
I agree that organic is not the same as 'low externalities'. Pricing in all the externalities would be the best thing.
As for the 'non-externality' costs the may be some extra demand for land but for that happen the demand for non-organic would have fallen significantly - most likely faster than supply. So in the short and medium term the prices of non -organic would actually fall.
World population will likely grow until there isn't enough to feed the world by any method. So the less toxic, time-tested method should continue to provide an alternative.
If one is concerned about yield, it would seem to me that corporate genetic engineering would be the concern. Monsanto and others wish to use genetic engineering to control our food supply via genetic use restriction technology. Their experimentation seems a much realer threat to the food chain than anything else.
Have you thought about the method which this ceiling will impose itself?
The end result of working to support an excessively large population of humans is an increase in the severity of these methods when they take effect.
The logical way to avoid nature's culling methods would be to decrease population by providing cheap/free birth control and encouraging a two-child limit.
I intend a self-imposed 2 child limit, we have 2 boys now. However, for those families or groups who appear to espouse drowning out other genetic variations by prolific reproduction how do you suppose we "encourage". That's kinda the hard part isn't it.
For me, in the UK, I'd stop any improved child allowances beyond the 2nd child. Give council tenants triple-bunkbeds (2 to a room if necessary) rather than a bedroom for each child (! which means having lots of kids can get you a huge house payed for by the taxpayer) - that may suck but reproducing beyond your means to support is socially irresponsible.
One might consider limiting to 2 maternity leave periods, child taxation (!? eg to account for education costs), ceasing all state sponsored IVF, ... what else?
I'm not sure we (as a society) want to reward not having offspring in the long term, just not having too many.
You may think it's pedantry you're practising - other people seem to cope with the dual meanings, personally I think you know exactly what is meant and are just being facetious (my father is just the same; in this instance he attempts to use the apparent absurdity as an attack against the intellectual standards of those espousing Organic, I think that attack fails and makes him look foolish, ditto for yourself).
"Organic" is not purely used in marketing but describes the method of production and indicates the specifics of the husbandry and nutrition of animals and the type of fertiliser and conditions of growth of plants. The specific definition is left to particular standards bodies.
Compare: Use of the word "judge" to mean "someone who determines what's right" dates way back, attempts to label a tiny subset of the population as "judges" [simply because they determine a specific type of judgement] is a more recent invention that bugs me.