This could potentially result in thousands of expensive cases for Google which means they will probably just follow through with most of the deletion requests. This in turn means that many fear cases like this, where somebody could be trying to clean up their past, getting rid of entries that display them in a negative light, if justified or not.
At its core the idea of the law is probably desirable but the current wording and its subsequent implementation mean that is a powerful weapon for everybody trying to clean their past from the web.
The practicality of this sort of law (which I really can't decide if I am in favour of or not) has been decided by our apathetic approach to Google's dominance of what quite frankly is an increasingly large part of our day-to-day lives.