I always wondered how much advertising, in any shape or form, works. I know for a fact that advertising didn't convince me to buy anything this far.
What is sad is that obvious marketing attempts work so well. One weird trick ads really do work. I was as surprised as anyone when we started running these for a client assuming that they would fail and we could stop. Sales nearly doubled for that ad group.
It's hard to blame the marketers for the dumbed down advertising when it works so well.