The very 1st photo after the header on that homepage sends the opposite message to your "Paper is making a comeback" with it's clearly computer-generated text on this image: http://f.cl.ly/items/0v1m0x0a2a35420m3a3L/styles.jpg

Handwriting the text, even if it were slightly less legible, would be better than doing it in a stock font in Photoshop.