Drawing The Line Between “Peer-to-Peer” And “Jerk” Technology
spectrum.ieee.org
spectrum.ieee.org
There were no gaps in the law when it came to Monkey Parking.
>Middle men are hated by those who see no value in human relationships.
Thanks for thinking you know me.
Tourists wandering round Edinburgh (or London) can stick out their arm and be guaranteed someone trained, vetted, and able to give them service at a standard price.
Locals can decide they want to take a risk and phone up a hire car company for a non-regulated price without guaranteed training, if they so wish.
The former is _totally_ worth it from a reputational point of view, as far as London/Edinburgh council is concerned.
I say that raising your hand to hail a car and making a call to hire a car are identical acts, and that it was inevitable that someone would come up with a way to make a call that was as simple as raising your hand. Are those cabs being hired or hailed? Does it matter? Why?
The regulation spoken of regarding the taxi industry is typically the medallion allowing hailed fares. There are typically other regulations which may apply, such as a commercial driver's license and commercial insurance. The latter two would be seen for bus, limo, truck and courier services. It is that group where Uber should fall, if anything, not taxi regulation which also includes regulation limiting the number.
Prebooked mini cabs are "expert mode" where, instead of being assigned to a taxi at random, you get to choose a taxi company. You can compare prices, look at reviews etc. This choice creates a competitive market to control prices and quality, allowing for softer touch regulation.
In the latter system, my taxi company which charges $100 a mile and only uses serial rapists driving 1978 Yugos would go out of business due to lack of demand. In the former system, either every taxi would soon cost the same, or people would bypass the random assignment, or people would stop using taxi ranks and hailing.
StubHub isn't doing that; the act (or venue) is. Knowingly selling something in bulk at 50% or less of its value is "encouraging people to buy up [the thing] for resale". They do it because they like packed houses.
edit: having read the article, it's striking that all three of these examples (entertainment tickets, public parking spaces, and restaurant reservations) involve valuable things being given away. It's difficult to complain that people who sign up for valuable freebies and resell them are "just being jerks"; even if Parking Monkey never makes its business work, and dies, it can perform the societally-valuable service of restructuring the parking situation generally.
If you aren't willing to pay X for a ticket simply don't buy it. I'm not willing to pay $100 for an NHL game so I don't buy tickets either from the box office or scalpers, however, I am willing to pay $50 so sometimes I'll go by the stadium 10 minutes after a game starts to see whats around for cheap from scalpers.
For things I really want to see I don't have time to stand in line or fuck around refreshing a browser madly / keeping track of all the events in the city, so I pay someone to stand in line for me, and work out an optimum price to keep tickets available.
I guess in today's economy being a jerk means understanding the time value of money.
Why is paying people to look for parking spots such a big deal? It reminds me of when the City of Vancouver arrested an old grandmother because she would go around adding nickels and dimes to people's parking meters.
If cities would invest in the kinds of infrastructure people actually want this would be far less of a big deal. Many people want parking spots, therefore if you reduce the number of spots it increases the value of them to the point where it becomes worthwhile to act as a parking scout.
If you want to read about the parking guys and restaurant reservation guys again, read the article. But if you have already read 7 articles about how evil they are, you can safely skip this one as it has nothing new.