If I were Charleston, my next order of business would be to enact an ordinance providing for exponentially increasing fines for businesses that materially encourage the violation of local laws.
If I were Charleston, my next order of business would be to enact an ordinance providing for exponentially increasing fines for businesses that materially encourage the violation of local laws.
Broadly speaking, there are rule-followers and rule-breakers. (If you subscribe to Kohlberg's theory of moral development, these are stage 4 vs. stage 6 arguments, though I don't want to make any implications here on which group is "more moral".)
The rule-followers hold laws as the highest moral authority, and if the laws are wrong, then what you're supposed to do is follow the rules to change the laws.
The rule-breakers hold their personal ideals as the highest moral authority, and if the laws are wrong, then what you're supposed to do is circumvent, subvert, or break them.
And these two groups are driving eachother nuts, and it happens in almost every single discussion because Uber is possibly one of the most distilled examples of a company of rule-breakers in recent history. Their response to Charleston is a classic example: "sure, OK, fine our drivers, we'll just keep breaking the laws anyway, because we disagree with them."
To respond directly to your comment, you're right that Charleston's laws might exist for a good reason. But, unless Charleston can explain that reason, Uber's supporters will continue to argue that the law is irrelevant. And, if Charleston were to follow something like your suggestion, and say, "no, really, our law is actually very important, we're going to break you if you don't follow it", then Uber's supporters would only become even more vocal.
By any normal definition of the term, ordinances imposed by the City of Charleston are imposed by a democratically elected government. Moreover, it is a municipal government which, at least in theory, is the most democratically responsive unit of government there is.
If Uber were operating in an oppressive dictatorship, I would be a lot more sympathetic to Uber's plight. But at least in theory, the laws they are ignoring in Charleston are laws enacted by representatives of the people of Charleston!
I suspect that Uber's supporters here will argue that this is really only a fiction and that the residents of Charleston agree with Uber, and not their own government. This is possible -- though I doubt anyone here actually knows if this is true, and it ignores the fact that, in a representative democracy, representatives are not expected to do only what their constituents want.
In any case, it's interesting to think about how commenters' attitudes about Uber relate to their views about democratic government.
And you completely disregard the disconnect between "people of Charleston" and their representatives. Two separate and distinct groups. And the connection between them does not necessarily imply that the actions of the representatives is representative of the will of the people of Charleston.
"it ignores the fact that, in a representative democracy, representatives are not expected to do only what their constituents want."
Ah yes, I just got to this part and you did mention it. Bravo, you've successfully dismantled Democracy without meaning to. Now if you could just take the next moral and logical leap, I've got some good literature regarding this topic:
Because, as you know, there is not a single bit of interference from money in politics or bullshit party politics, or cronyism. No sir! We'll have none of that in good 'ol Chucktown.
This, by the way, is probably not true. It is just the first internet-popular rule breaker in recent history. It is pretty easy to imagine an alternate universe where commenters on a popular internet forum supported, e.g., large power companies' treating environmental fines as simply a cost of doing business, instead of attempting to comply with them, because they see cheap power for industry and progress as more important than environmental concerns.
On the other hand, I can only see positive externalities from Uber.
And if you literally can't think of any negative externalities that Uber generates, I submit that you haven't approached the problem dispassionately. As people have repeatedly pointed out, there are concerns about Uber's liability insurance (even now that it offers its own limited coverage -- externality: uncompensated, injured people), policy concerns about surge pricing (externality: people can't afford to get where they're going at peak usage times), policy concerns that Uber drivers are free to turn down passengers (externality: possible discrimination), concerns that decrentalization makes it more difficult to ensure that vehicles are safe for passengers (externality: possible injuries), concerns that decentralization makes it more difficult to ensure that drivers have safe driving records and clean criminal histories (externality: possible crime against passengers more possible injuries), difficulty verifying that drivers are actually covered by the insurance that they (and Uber) claim covers them in the absence of formal licensing (externality: uncompensated injuries). These are just off the top of my head. Maybe you don't find all of these these persuasive, and maybe you think that the benefits of Uber outweigh all of these (I happen to agree!).
And, to be clear, I think that Uber is doing much (MUCH) less harm than most serial polluters by ignoring the relevant regulations. The point, though, is just that Uber isn't the first company to take the attitude that it is free to ignore the law. It's just the first one I can think of that is also popular.
Not at all, it's an economic issue. Pollution imposes clear, observable, quantifiable costs. That's the externality; no moralizing necessary.
You seem to be very confused about the rest of the stuff so I'm not going to bother addressing it.
I really wish you would, since that's the substance of the comment, and I'm pretty sure I'm not actually confused -- though perhaps you disagree. (Note that your disagreeing, and my being "very confused" are not actually the same thing.) And you should do a little more thinking about what constitutes a "negative" externality -- sometimes it is clear that it constitutes a cognizable economic "cost," but other cases are no so clear cut.
Here is some recommended reading: http://repository.law.umich.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=... Especially page 911. The point is not just that a value judgment is necessary to determine whether something is a cost or benefit (though sometimes it is) but also that a value judgment is needed to determine whether a would-be externality is the sort of thing that a person or entity should be expected to internalize.
From what I can see, there doesn't seem to be a moral categorical imperative behind the choices that the 'rule-breakers' here are making. They are doing so because it is expedient. They make more money in an easier way by breaking the rule and so they do it. If we applied the universality required here to that, this must mean that anyone who can make money in an easier way by breaking it, should.
Of course we could describe the Uber-side here as relentless warriors for freedom, but that is unlikely to be accurate. Uber drivers I have spoken to do not have that as a prime motivation. I take Uber every day, and love it, but I feel you're not describing the situation accurately.
The drivers themselves may well only do it for the money, and I wouldn't be surprised at all if Uber's actual sole purpose is making money, but the overwhelming commentary from Uber's spokerspersons has been centered around providing a service that people want, which keeps the debate framed on the ethics of rule-following vs. rule-breaking.
To make an analogy, it's clear that civil disobedience should not be practiced against laws forbidding murder or theft, but in the case of jim crow laws or similarly unjust laws I would fully support acts of civil disobedience.
Also, does it not bother you that this particular form of civil disobedience is only available with extremely deep pockets?
One could argue the Uber should be punished, but that they should do it anyway.
According to whom / by what creed? I certainly do not believe that, and it is clear that a large chunk of the country does not either, if you look at the routine flouting, of, for instance, jaywalking laws, underage drinking laws, gambling laws, marijuana laws, and so on.
Law always gets the last word though. The thing that's interesting is that the US seems to let things go for a while before clamping down. The whole "present a warning about browser cookies" thing in the EU is a bit of a disaster.