Not a great parallel - those taxi drivers can become Uber (or lyft, or sidecar, etc) drivers
Not a great parallel - those taxi drivers can become Uber (or lyft, or sidecar, etc) drivers
on the other hand, uber price will only go up. until only the rich is allowed to be driven in the city.
SF taxi rates are regulated. This can lead to scarcity for everyone.
Uber prices are not regulated. This can lead to scarcity for the poor.
(Morally speaking, which is better?)
So long as there's a linear (or perhaps "convex" might be a better term) response, then yes, more competition and lower barriers tends to drive prices down.
Traffic is not one of them. Adding a few percentage more drivers can drastically slow everyone down. If small vehicles are the only way to get from place to place, and since the price of the trip on average is a profit for the driver, then it's advantageous for paid drivers to have more drivers on the streets. This causes more congestion, which causes longer drive times, which in turn requires more drivers to meet the demand. This is a stable solution, so is an example where more competition and lower barriers to entry end up increasing transportation costs.
The city doesn't want congested streets. They make it hard to get business done, including goods deliveries and scheduling face-to-face meetings, and add pollution and more chances for accidents with serious injuries.
Instead, observe that my preconditions are incorrect. There are other modes of transportation, including walking, biking, and public or private mass transit. A city might introduce a medallion system as one way to limit congestion, and use the resulting artificial scarcity as a way to entice people to use other transportation schemes which are overall better for the city.
The optimal economic solution would be to tax all traffic, have toll roads, or some kind of technological solution. I can't see any city ever doing that though. But it's only relevant if it really is a serious problem.
The parent comment was ridiculous. It asserted that eliminating $100k barrier to entry, eliminating a monopoly (their own words), and increasing competition would drive prices up. You could maybe argue that congestion would increase, but prices almost certainly would not.
In any case, the SF mayor wants to raise the number of medallions as a source of revenue, so it's clear they are not limiting the number in order to influence transportation modality use. (The legislative history suggests that a goal of Prop K, which put the current regulations into place, was to prevent oligarchies in the local taxi cab industry.)
FWIW, http://www.emmanuelcombe.org/moor.pdf does an overview of what economists have written on the topic. Some papers conclude that taxi deregulation does what you think it would do, some papers conclude otherwise. There's no clear consensus.
See http://www.thelocal.se/20090112/16868 for some of the situations that occur in a deregulated taxi marketplace.
The history of taxi medallions in SF shows that Prop K was voted on to prevent oligarchies.
if you have problems with the number of taxis, you don't solve it by throwing the hole system in the garbage and going full liberal. you put the people doing the bad planning to answer for their bad work.
I know it is very hard for you to understand why taxi prices being regulated is a bad thing, you being a young yuppie in san francisco. but i hope you still have it when you are older, retired, with no close family, having to move around.