We already tax capital gains on short-term investments as income. Taxing long-term capital gains at the same rate as income would have a number of other unpleasant consequences
- It would eliminate the incentive to hold investments for longer than 365 days
- It would reduce the incentive to invest in the market (since you would quite literally be paying double taxes on this income, instead of more like 1.5x the tax (which is what we sometimes misleadingly refer to as "double taxation"))
Regarding point #1 - if you sell a stock before 1 year, you already pay normal income tax on any gains. This encourages buy-and-hold, long-term investing, which I believe most people on HN would agree is good for the economy at large, as it reduces volatility and ensures that shareholder incentives are better aligned with growing the company.
Regarding point #2, which is mildly controversial (but IMHO only because it is misunderstood): it is good to encourage investments in the economy, because this is literally how business raise capital. Readers of Hacker News should be well aware of the importance of this in the private equity markets (ie, venture capital, which is technically a form of private equity). Similarly, in the public markets, it is good to create incentives for people to park their money in places which help spur the economy[0].
[0] In theory (obviously not always in practice), providing capital to a business has the potential to stimulate the economy more than providing capital to an individual, as the business uses that capital to pursue a profit, hire employees, etc.