http://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2013/07/linus-...
http://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2013/07/linus-...
It's like the second amendment of developer communication. That sort of verbal weaponry should be available, but its use still needs to be justified.
You are making this up.
If you don't, then you should have no problem producing a handful of examples, because 100s of dev doing this all the time will have LKML and other places overflowing with them.
http://sarah.thesharps.us/2013/07/15/no-more-verbal-abuse/ https://lkml.org/lkml/2013/7/15/329
There are also plenty of examples here.
http://fortunes.cat-v.org/kernelnewbies/
Just look for "crap" or "s--t" or "idiot" or "Viro". Note especially that these are presented as humor, i.e. approvingly and not necessarily showing the worst examples that are just mean without even the saving grace of being slightly funny.
This is not an illusion, not a new or unremarked-upon phenomenon. You're the one making things up when you act as though some reasonable person might believe otherwise.
> The canonical example, of course, is Sarah Sharp.
In which she had an issue with Linus specifically.
> There are also plenty of examples here.
None of which are the examples of kernel devs brainlessly parroting Linus abrasive commenting style, which is what you've been originally claiming -
> hundreds of other kernel developers imitate his most severe tones all the time
happens pretty easily, it seems.
Sometimes people deserve it, but often times they just don't. The people doing this are not paragons of judgement like Linus (arguably) is.
This is interesting when one compares it with other projects such as Django which have gone the whole other way in addressing modern views of how to approach diversity, gender issues, conduct etc.
Yes, good debaters shouldn't resort to emotionally laden language, but the best debaters just ignore it in the first place.
English also isn't my first language and I avoid such discussions, because I don't feel equipped for them.
What you said about "the best debaters just ignore it in the first place" is incorrect. Debates are meant to convince others, so the debater must take the listeners into account. If the listeners can be swayed by the opponent's emotionally laden language - and we are all human - then the debater must not ignore it.
The obvious responses are to use emotionally laden language in kind, or to call out the opponent for dressing bad logic behind good clothing.
The opposite also happens; a common complaint of highly reactionary commentators is that people aren't responding 'civilly' to their regressive nonsense about the threat posed by the gays or how women's' place is in the home or whatever, but are instead using rude words and personal attacks.
And there we go, talking shit about someone talking shit, all while complaining the when someone else talks shit it is not acceptable.
> I don't care how frustrated you are, learn to control your emotions. Its very much possible to be direct without being an ass. Probably more effective too.
Well, apply the same logic to yourself before requiring it from someone else.