Evolution is _really_ good at gaming the system. Unless you are very careful at specifying all of the constraints that you care about you can end up with a solution that is very clever but not quite what you had in mind. Here power consumption is the issue. If you tried to evolve a sturdy chair you might end up with something that is 1mm tall. or maybe a fuel efficient car that exploits continental drift.
For circuit simulation there are a bunch of potential pitfalls beyond power consumption. I think you would probably need to do multiple runs with components of varying values within their specified precision. I can see evolution getting some sort of benefit by exploiting the fact that two identically specced components behave _exactly_ the same way. Something that would not happen in real life.