We did the opposite. We raised the price [$50] and will only provide a year of free updates. Extra years come at a comparatively small cost. People hated being asked to upgrade regularly and we obviously didn't want to go years between adding major features. It seemed like the only way.
One interesting thing we have done, is offer a "lifetime upgrade" option for both upgrades and new purchases. About 30% of our customers buy it. It costs 50% more on a new purchase or 100% more if you're upgrading, but you get all future upgrades. It's a win for customers who want that, and it's definitely a win for us.