Hacker News Reader

Comment by snowwrestler | Hacker News Reader

I doubt that all, and maybe any, of those recommendations can be followed by the medical staff currently responding to the outbreak in Africa. We're talking about an area of the world that struggles to provide any clean water to humans at all, and where many rural residents are actively hostile toward medical staff.

View on HN

I know they're following some set of protocols, as it was reported at least one of the infected doctors claimed to have abided by them. I have no idea the degree to which they match the linked recommendations. Previous outbreaks have been in the same areas, though, so more infections with (we hope) the same or better protocols followed (presumably) comparably well is still worrisome.

I found this comment to have an undertone of ignorance.

1) Implying a cluster of 54 countries are all homogeneous, have poor health standard, etc

2) "Struggles to provide any clean water to humans at all" - this is much more heresy than fact. Please rely on statistics

African countries by no means are world superpowers, but this comment is pretty ignorant. Please think twice about such comments, they can be interpreted as offensive

Guinea, Liberia, and Sierra Leone are all poor countries with limited access to health care.

Additionally, http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Water_supply_in_Sierra_Leone opens with "Water supply in Sierra Leone is characterized by limited access to safe drinking water."

The parent made no statement that all of Africa is so limited, only that the outbreak was in Africa. The countries most affected by the outbreak were correctly described.

I did not mean to imply that all of Africa lacks clean water and is hostile to doctors--just the areas of the current outbreak. Sorry for the imprecise language.

I think it is instructive that ebola has not spread to the more developed areas of Africa in 30 years. Compare to AIDS, which also originated in Africa and rapidly spread into cities worldwide.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com