Hacker News Reader

Comment by UnoriginalGuy | Hacker News Reader

Plus in the US you often have to show your ID (e.g. driver's licence), whereas I've never been challenged for my ID when using Chip and Pin in Europe.

View on HN

> Plus in the US you often have to show your ID

They're not allowed to do that: "Both Visa and MasterCard prohibit merchants from requiring customer ID as a condition for accepting their credit or debit cards. All you need is a signed card, and of course the signatures must match [1]"

[1] http://www.consumerreports.org/cro/news/2011/02/can-a-mercha...

That's absolutely not the reality on the ground. Just yesterday I got challenged for my ID when making a sub-$10 purchase in the US.

That isn't unusual.

That's not been my experience: I use cards for every single purchase, which adds up to hundreds* per year, and have never been asked for ID. In any case, it's true that they're not allowed to require it. The link I gave above suggests the following as recourse:

"If you're a Visa cardholder and a merchant presses you for an ID, Visa says you should notify your card issuer. In the case of Amex, notify American Express directly. MasterCard customers should report the violation by visiting the company's merchant violation web page."

*Edit: hundreds of transactions per year

They also don't usually ask for an unsigned card.

I probably get asked for ID less than 1% of the time. In general it tends to be in odd locations too. In my experience a less than $20 dollar purchase is more likely to have the employee ask for my ID than a $200 purchase.

It happens to me significantly more than 1% of the time, I'd say closer to 10%. And as you say it has nothing to do with the amount, $8? ID. $500? No ID.

I think it is more related to the amount of fraud the vendor experiences and they get pressure from the processor to reduce it, therefore they implement ID checking to counteract it a bit.

Seldom, while it's true that it does happen occasionally, it ends up being very rare in most places except for very expensive purchases.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com